Butcher

Chapter 4

4

BUTCHER

Moving to the beat of the music, I squeezed Kaylee’s ass, our bodies pressed together and my dick threatened to come alive at any second. The sparkle in her eye told me we were on the same page. We were going to go upstairs to my hotel room and not leave until we were both satisfied.

But as we grinded together, my gaze moved to the bar, and I locked eyes with Sexton. He placed his drink on the bar and strode toward us. He gave me a brief nod and stepped behind Kaylee and moved his hips in sync with ours. She rested her head against his chest and the three of us danced the rest of the song with her in between us.

Once the song was over, I leaned forward so they could both hear me over the music and I asked, “Should we go to my room?”

Kaylee bobbed her head and, without hesitation, Sexton agreed and motioned for us to follow him out of the club. We slipped out the doors without any of our teammates stopping us and hurried toward the hotel elevators.

Pressing the call button, one set of doors opened, and we went inside. The doors shut, and I hit the number for my floor.

“So, um.” Kaylee cleared her throat. “I’ve actually never been with two guys at once.”

My gaze flicked over to Sexton’s and I said, “That’s okay. We won’t do anything you don’t want to do.”

“No, I want to. I just thought I should be upfront about it,” she replied.

“What about you?” I asked my teammate.

“I’ve had a threesome, but only with two women,” he admitted.

I grinned. “I’ve done both.”

“You have?” His forehead creased.

Only Coop knew what I was going to confess, but given Sexton and I were about to share an incredible experience together, I felt it was time to tell him too.

“I’m bi,” I declared.

Sexton blinked. “Oh, wow. I didn’t know.”

“Is that okay?” I wondered. He knew about Coop and hadn’t seemed to be bothered by his sexuality but maybe he felt I would make a pass at him once we got behind closed doors.

He swallowed. “Yeah.”

“Good.” I grinned.

“So, we’re in expert hands?” Kaylee smirked.

“Yeah, you are.” I winked at her and then looked at Sexton. He didn’t say anything.

The elevator came to a stop, dinged, and the doors opened. Stepping out onto my floor, I grabbed Kaylee’s hand and led her to my room while Sexton walked a step behind us.

Once inside my room, I locked the door for good measure and then stripped out of my suit jacket. It was customary for hockey players to wear suits to and from games and since I’d gone to eat with my family, and then attended Coop’s wedding afterward, I hadn’t changed. Neither had Sexton.

Kaylee had to have changed because I didn’t think she had worn the little gold number to the game. She looked smoking hot in it, but I wanted to strip it off of her so badly.

“Can I get either of you a drink?” I offered, tossing my jacket onto a chair.

“Please,” Sexton replied.

Kaylee took a seat on the end of the king-sized bed. “Sure. I’ll take vodka and diet if you have it.”

“Coming right up.”

I grabbed a few bottles of Tito’s from the minibar, a can of Diet Coke, and a bottle of water.

“I’ll have whatever you’re having,” Sexton said to me.

I squeezed his shoulder, trying to put him more at ease. Seeing as neither one of them had experienced a threesome with two guys, I was going to take things slowly. I didn’t know how far Sexton wanted me to go with him and I didn’t want to risk souring the mood in some way.

“Get comfortable and relax. I’ll make our drinks.”

He nodded once and then slipped out of his jacket. I watched as he sat next to Kaylee and they stared at each other.

“You look so beautiful in that dress,” he praised her.

“Thank you.” She blushed and tucked her light brown hair behind her ear.

I turned my attention back to the drinks, but still listened as they talked.

“Nervous?” Sexton asked her.

“Kinda.”

“Me too,” he admitted. “But we can take it slow.”

“Okay.”

“Do you like this?”

I peeked over my shoulder to see he was lightly running his fingers up her bare arm.

“Yes,” she answered.

“And this?” His hand slid across her breasts, which were covered with her dress.

“Yes.”

I turned back to focus on pouring water into my cup.

“What about this?” Sexton wondered.

When I turned around, his lips were on hers, his hand cupping the back of her neck. In my head, I wanted to be the first to kiss her, but as I watched him open her mouth with his and slip his tongue inside, I wasn’t jealous. No, I was so fucking turned on that I wanted to drop the cups in my hand and join in on the fun.

Instead, I put the drinks on the counter where I’d been mixing them and then sat on the other side of Kaylee. Sexton broke his mouth free and his stare met mine.

“Don’t stop on my account.” I smirked.

“You sure?” He arched a brow.

“Oh, yeah.” I slid the strap of her dress off her shoulder and leaned forward, placing light kisses down the slope of her neck.

Sexton returned to her mouth, and while they kissed, I nipped the top of her shoulder and slid my hand up her thigh. I inched the hem of her dress higher and higher until my fingers glided across the fabric of her panties. She moaned into Sexton’s mouth.

“Damn. Already wet for us?” I grinned.

She nodded and Sexton pulled back again. “Can I taste you?”

“Please,” she breathed.

He slipped off the bed, hooking his fingers into the lace around her hips, and tugged them down.

I grabbed her dress and pulled it over her head, leaving her naked and sexy as fuck. My mouth watered.

“Fuck, you’re exquisite.” I admired every inch of her.

Sexton pulled her hips to the edge of the mattress, and she gasped as he took his first taste.

“Fucking sweet too.”

Kaylee whimpered, throwing her head back as she enjoyed the pleasure Sexton was giving her.

I caressed one of her perky tits, then took the nipple into my mouth and swirled my tongue around the peak.

But I wanted more.

Cupping her cheek, I popped my mouth off of her nipple and then took her mouth with mine. She purred as our tongues moved together.

“You want to suck me while he eats you?” I asked her.

She nodded, staring into my eyes.

Getting off the bed, I watched Sexton eat her pussy while I took off all of my clothes. My dick was standing at attention and ready for Kaylee’s hungry mouth. Giving my cock a few tugs, I knelt on the bed next to where she was lying back on her elbows. She parted her plump lips, and I slid inside her warm, wet mouth.

As she sucked my dick, I looked down at where Sexton was between Kaylee’s spread legs. He replaced his mouth with his hand and worked her pussy fast, rubbing her clit and making her gasp around my shaft.

I could smell her sweet juices in the air. While I fucked her mouth, my stare locked with my teammate’s. Still pumping his fingers into her, he leaned down and sucked her clit. As he increased her pleasure, he stared at what she was doing to me. It seemed he couldn’t take his eyes off of the way she was sucking my hard length.

“I’m gonna come,” she panted, pulling her lips off of me for a brief second.

I licked my bottom lip, watching him on his knees as he brought Kaylee closer and closer to her first orgasm. He continued to stare up at me with hooded eyes, and I swear a look of need shined back at me. Or maybe that was wishful thinking because I would give anything to have him in the same position. But instead of him eating Kaylee’s pussy, I wanted his lips wrapped around my dick.

A few moments later, Kaylee pulled her head off of me and cried out as her body spasmed with her release.

When she stopped shaking, I got off the bed and grabbed the condoms I’d brought with me. As I rolled the latex over myself, Sexton finally stripped out of his suit and I watched him get naked. I couldn’t help it. He didn’t say anything as he threw his clothes onto the floor. Even though I’d seen him in the locker room and in the shower, I felt as though I was seeing my teammate in a different light. Levi Sexton was hard everywhere and thinking about tasting him made my mouth water.

Swallowing and turning my attention to Kaylee, I walked to where she still lay on the bed. “You want to suck Levi while I fuck you from behind?”

Sexton’s head snapped up and I shrugged. Saying his first name felt right in that moment.

“Okay.” She got onto all fours in the center of the mattress, keeping her gold heels on.

What I really wanted to do was slide into her while Sexton was in her other hole. To feel his dick inside of her as we both fucked her. But even though he had watched me some, I wasn’t going to press him for more. Anything we did that caused us to touch had to be up to him.

While he got onto the bed so she could take his impressive dick into her pretty little mouth, I lined up between her legs. Her round ass was spread just enough for me to see her glistening pussy and I bent down and ran my tongue up her slit.

“Mm.” She bucked as I moaned my approval. “She is sweet like you said.”

I bet she’d be even sweeter if I tasted her off your lips.

Sexton was the first to taste her mouth and pussy, but I was about to be the first to feel how good she felt wrapped around my cock.

“The perfect bedtime snack.” He winked.

“Yeah, she is,” I agreed and nudged my crown against her opening. “You ready for me, sweetness?”

She wiggled her ass as she continued to suck Sexton’s dick.

Sliding into her, I watched my shaft get swallowed by her tight cunt and when I was all the way in, I glanced up to see Sexton’s gaze was on where I was sliding into her. His stare revealed a look of want that made me wonder if maybe he wasn’t as straight as I thought he was.

“Fuck, you feel amazing.” I pumped my hips a few times.

Sexton reached down and cupped her breast as his pelvis matched my thrusts.

“Fuck yeah,” Kaylee said, slipping off his dick and using her hand to pump him. “Fuck me harder.”

And I did. I picked up my pace and rammed into her over and over. While I did so, I locked eyes with my teammate. Something unspoken passed between us. Maybe some sort of approval or want or need, but I fought with myself not to lean forward and take his mouth with mine.

He gasped, breaking our eye contact, and looked down as Kaylee began sucking him again.

“That’s it, sweetheart. Fuck me with your mouth,” he said.

“So fucking hot,” I rasped as I watched her swallow him whole. “You gonna come around my dick?”

“Mm hmm,” Kaylee moaned.

“Then I want you to turn over and let us paint your chest with our cum when we’re coming.” I slapped her ass cheek.

“Oh god,” she gasped and pumped Sexton’s cock with her hand. “I want that so bad.”

“Then come for me, sweetness. Let me feel you squeeze my dick.”

Her pussy pulsed around my shaft as I continued to thrust into her.

“I’m close,” Sexton stated.

“Me too,” I agreed.

“Come on, sweetheart. Come for us,” Sexton coaxed.

“I want to come with both of you fucking me,” she panted.

Sexton and I locked eyes again, and I wanted nothing more than either to fuck her in the ass while he took her pussy or the other way around.

But he shook his head slightly and then said, “I’m too close. Maybe next time.”

Next time? I could live with that.

Reaching around, my middle finger found her clit and I rubbed it in fast circles. It was her undoing as her back arched and she shattered around me.

“Ah shit,” I gasped. “I’m gonna come.”

I pulled out of her and she hurried to lie on her back. Slipping the condom off, I pumped my dick while Sexton did the same to his. Kaylee waited below us, her bright blue eyes looking up at us.

My balls pulled up, and I looked at Sexton. “I’m almost there.”

“Me too,” he groaned.

“I want to taste both of you,” Kaylee admitted.

“You want us to come on your face, sweetness?” I grinned.

“Come all over me,” she urged.

“Fuck,” Sexton hissed.

We got into position above her head and while we stroked ourselves, I watched his hand move up and down his cock. I bit my bottom lip and while white ropes of hot cum squirted from my tip, I couldn’t stop staring at my teammate. I was too afraid to look at his eyes and see what he was looking at, because I wanted him to be watching me. Wanted him to be turned on by seeing me shoot my release.

“Shit,” he groaned as his jizz shot from his shaft.

Looking down, our cum mixed together on Kaylee’s lips and chin and, like a good girl, she stuck her tongue out and licked her mouth clean.

I needed to taste him.

Knowing I couldn’t touch him, I leaned down and sucked Kaylee’s tongue. She was salty and sweet and everything about the moment felt right. The mixture of all three of us was like some secret love potion because, as I helped lick her mouth clean, my dick started to get hard again.

But I felt the bed move and when I pulled back from her mouth, Sexton was grabbing his clothes.

“You good?” I asked him.

“Yeah.”

“We can clean up and go again,” I suggested.

“Nah,” he said. “It’s getting late and after the night we’ve had, I’m ready to crash.”

I wasn’t going to make the situation awkward, so while he slipped on his clothes, I put my boxers on and then handed Kaylee her dress.

“I should probably head out too,” she stated.

“I’ll walk you to your room,” Sexton offered.

While Kaylee went to the bathroom to clean up, Sexton and I waited awkwardly. Once she was done, he moved to the door and opened it. Kaylee slipped out before him and then, with a head nod, they were gone.

A week later, Sexton, Orlov, Nystrom, Friberg, Cardinale, and I were on our annual guys’ trip to Lake Winnipesaukee. After every season, we would go away to relax and unwind after the season. Coop usually came, but since he and Ford were in wedded bliss, they were off on their honeymoon to St. Bart’s.

Orlov, Nystrom, and I rode up together while the rest of the guys, including Sexton, drove in another vehicle.

The morning after the threesome, the team had to fly home together, except for Coop who received special permission to leave for his honeymoon directly from Las Vegas. I kept my distance from Sexton, wanting to give him the opportunity to approach me since he had hightailed it out of my hotel room, but he never did. He joked and laughed with the other guys, but never once talked to me.

Was he ashamed of what happened? He seemed all for it when we were dancing and maybe it was the heat of the moment, but I had to assume he enjoyed every second we were with Kaylee. But then he came, and it was like with his climax, reality set it. Or maybe he thought I was going to bring it up in front of the guys. He had to know me better than that. We weren’t super close, but he had to believe I would keep our secret.

And I would. Especially when I shared my own secret with him.

Walking out of the bedroom I was staying in at the lake house, I strolled into the kitchen to find Sexton at the island sipping a beer. I grabbed a bottle of Tito’s and a cup to put ice in. The other guys were out back playing cornhole, so I took the opportunity to find out what was up with him.

“Can we talk?” I asked as I filled the red plastic cup with ice.

He took a deep breath. “Sure.”

I put the cup on the island as I turned to face him. “Are you regretting what happened?”

It took him a good ten seconds before he said, “No.”

“Then why do I feel like you’re walking on eggshells around me?”

“I’m not sure how to act.” He picked at the label on his beer bottle.

“Like yourself.”

“I’m trying,” he admitted and looked out the window to where the guys were. “It’s just that … I felt things.”

“What things?” I leaned on the countertop.

“Nothing. Just forget it.” He stood, but my words stopped him from leaving.

“Come on. You can tell me.”

He didn’t speak.

“Would you feel differently if you didn’t know I was bisexual?” I asked.

Sexton looked down at the floor for a beat and then spun back toward me. “I don’t know.”

“Are you questioning—” Before I could finish my question, Orlov walked in through the back door.

“Butch, we’re getting hungry. Do you need help with the steaks?” he asked.

I lifted off the island’s surface. “Just making myself a drink and then I’ll get them seasoned, and the grill started.”

“Sweet.” Orlov went back outside, and Sexton followed him out.