Stealing the Show (PolyAm Fam #3)

Chapter 9

nine

leo

I had both of these beautiful ladies just where I wanted them. And I’d had all day to bring up the idea I’d mentioned to Raine but had failed to do it. I couldn’t bring it up during sex…but that was what remained on the table as far as opportunities were concerned.

We’d eaten a hearty dinner of grilled steaks, baked potatoes, asparagus, flaky croissants, and wine, and, after a stimulating conversation, we climbed into the hot tub to continue our time together. Surrogacy didn’t seem like a hot tub topic to me. Especially not when my wife and Raine started fondling each other under the surface of the bubbling water.

“That feels good,” floated out of Raine’s mouth, more breath than voice, as my wife stroked her back.

“Sore from the hike?” she asked, massaging the tension out of the younger woman’s shoulders.

“No,” she shook her head, “not from the hike, but maybe from poring over those plays the last few days.”

My wife’s voice oozed with concern and sensuality, “Oh, well, we don’t want that. We want to get you nice and relaxed. Do you want more wine?”

“More wine might be nice.” She opened her eyes briefly, and they landed on me before drifting closed again.

“I’ll pour you some.” I scooted the tray with the glasses and half-full wine bottle closer to the edge of the hot tub and filled all three glasses to the halfway mark. Then I crossed the bubbly cauldron to deliver their glasses.

“Thank you, handsome.” Maggie smiled and took a sip while Raine did the same.

I watched while they both placed their glasses on the edge of the tub and Maggie maneuvered herself so she was straddling our guest. “I need those lips,” she sighed as she tilted Raine’s chin up to meet her mouth. As she hungrily devoured her lips, my cock swelled under the water.

God, I wanted to sink this cock deep inside my wife while she licked Raine’s pussy. I wanted one of them to ride my cock while the other rode my face. Just thinking about all the different combinations and positions we could get into tonight made my balls tight with need.

The other night when Raine was here, I just watched. But after she left, Maggie let me fuck her over the couch like I had the night after she danced with Raine at The Barn. I came so fucking hard imagining this scene unfolding right now in reality.

Could the reality live up to the fantasy? That was always the question, wasn’t it?

“Hey, what about me?” I captured their attention. “I like watching and all, but I sure would like some attention too.” I stood from the water, gripping my thick, hard cock in one hand, steam rising off my body as two pairs of hooded eyes zeroed in on my hand stroking up and then back down again.

Raine stood and walked toward me, pressing her body against me as she pulled me down into a kiss. My cock throbbed against her thighs as her tongue tangled with mine. Then Maggie came behind her, reaching her hands between us to cup and fondle Raine’s breasts as we continued to kiss.

“Come here,” Maggie directed us both, tugging Raine down onto the seat next to her and jerking me forward to stand in front of them. My cock was at the perfect height for their mouths.

Oh, damn…

“What do you think of my husband’s cock?” Maggie took Raine’s hand and wrapped her fingers around my thickness.

“It looks absolutely perfect. Nice length, so thick.” She stroked me from base to tip, making my eyes roll back in my head.

“I think you should see how it feels in your mouth,” Maggie suggested, and I whimpered as Raine lowered her head, her tongue darting out to tentatively lick a stripe around my head.

“Mmm…” She moaned as she licked up my shaft, teasing me as Maggie cupped my balls and gently kneaded them.

“He likes to have them played with,” she shared with our guest.

“Duly noted.” She swiped up my cock again with her tongue before putting the tip in her mouth and sucking lightly while Maggie squeezed my balls a little harder.

Fuck…these two…they were gonna make me come so fucking hard. I hoped I could last long enough to give them both plenty of orgasms.

“See if you can take him all the way down your throat,” Maggie challenged Raine as she looked up at me with a devilish glint in her eyes.

Raine accepted the challenge, sliding her mouth down my shaft until she sputtered and choked. She made it about three-quarters of the way, sending a shock of pleasure right through me.

“That’s pretty good,” Maggie praised. “Here, watch me.” She positioned herself closer to me as Raine moved aside. My wife sank her mouth down on my cock, taking me in my entirety to the back of her throat, almost as though she unhinged her jaw. She managed to use the back of her throat to suck at my head, making me weak in the knees.

“Fuck, you better stop that, or I’m gonna come down your throat,” I warned her.

“Oops, better back off—wanna save some cum for Raine.” She popped off, licking her lips. “What’s wrong, big guy? Can’t handle two hungry ladies?”

“We’ll see if you can handle this cock buried deep inside your pussies, how about that?” I backed up and climbed out of the tub, handing both of them a towel. “Dry off, then get on the bed. I’ll be right there.”

I needed to cool down for a second, or I’d never last. My two beautiful lovers followed my instructions, drying each other off with their towels, stopping to fondle and kiss as they went.

Fuck me. These two were gonna be hard to handle. And I was gonna love every minute of it.

I put the hot tub cover on as they made their way inside. I hoped moving around in the brisk night air would soften my erection, at least a little, but I was hard as ever as I returned to our bedroom to find my two little cumsluts lying dutifully side by side on the bed. They were giggling and touching each other, but they had obeyed my command.

“Good girls,” I praised them as I climbed onto the mattress, my knees sinking into the softness as I crawled toward them. They were both naked, their lovely curves displayed for my viewing pleasure.

Their bodies were both beautiful but in different ways. Maggie was a little taller, with smaller breasts but bigger nipples. Her stomach was rounded with a soft curve that slightly draped over her mound. Her shoulders were narrower, and her hips were wider than Raine’s.

Raine was a bit more compact but with larger breasts and smaller nipples. The curve between her waist and hips wasn’t as defined as Maggie’s, but her thighs were nice and thick, and I knew that ass was begging to be played with.

“Like what you see?” Maggie’s voice broke the silence as I studied the masterpieces of their nude forms.

“Well, what do you think?” I rocked back on my heels, presenting my thick cock for their perusal. “I’m just trying to decide what I want to do first and to whom.”

“I think Raine’s pussy needs some attention,” Maggie suggested with a soft smile.

Memories of kissing her by the waterfall flooded my mind. Her lips were so soft, all I could think about was tasting them again. I grinned and nodded at my wife before swinging a leg over Raine’s hips to straddle her. “May I kiss you?”

She nodded, her lips parted in anticipation. I cradled her head in one hand as I lowered my mouth to hers, tentatively brushing my lips against hers before swiping at the seam between them with my tongue. She opened to me, allowing me to sweep my tongue inside, swallowing her moan as it escaped her throat. I nibbled on her lips as she arched into me, pressing her bare pussy into my engorged cock.

Oh god, I was going to enjoy fucking her for the first time. But I needed to make her come on my tongue first.

I broke the kiss and moved down her body, kissing every inch along the way. As soon as I made it to her breasts, Maggie rolled toward her, guiding Raine’s head to turn her way so she could kiss her while I teased her nipples into hard points. Her little mewls of need spurred me on as I continued in a southerly direction to her adorable softly dimpled stomach and her mound, decorated with springy black curls.

Maggie usually preferred herself clean-shaven, but there was something about natural pubic hair I found so earthy and enticing. I breathed in her cherries and vanilla scent as she thrust her hips up to me, begging for more contact. I held her thighs down with my hands as I pressed kisses to her curls and continued lower until I could part her labia with the tip of my tongue.

She jolted underneath me as I found her clit, teasing it until it swelled more and more with each stroke. Her sweet flavor burst on my taste buds as I dove in, fucking her slick pink flesh with my tongue until she was writhing beneath me. I stilled for a moment, lifting my chin to witness my wife suckling Raine’s nipples as Raine’s fingers twisted in her hair and expletives fell from her lips.

Her thighs tensed as I slid a finger inside her, curling to hit her G-spot, and she bowed off the bed in response. “Fuck, don’t stop,” she gasped as Maggie moved to her other nipple, eliciting a squeal that was somewhere on the edge of pain and pleasure.

She was close, and I couldn’t wait for her to come on my face like she did Maggie’s the other night. But I wanted to draw out her orgasm, edge her a bit to make it more intense. She was leaking juices onto my tongue as I continued to lash her clit and fuck her with two fingers, but I held back a little. She grunted in frustration as she thrust up into my face, grinding her mound into me.

“More…oh my god…I’m so fucking close…”

I had her right where I wanted her. I considered sheathing myself in a condom and sliding deep inside her to feel her quaking from the inside out, but, no, I wanted to give this to her. I suddenly remembered our conversation over coffee—how she said she would think about my proposition—but we hadn’t had a chance to discuss it.

A wild fantasy of fucking her raw and spurting my seed deep inside her, breeding her, rocked through me. I damn near thought I was going to come right there, my cock pressed against the mattress as my fingers rocked into Raine and my tongue circled her clit.

But Maggie had moved again and was now straddling Raine’s face, letting Raine lick her cunt while she held on to the headboard for balance. Fuck, that was hot. My wife’s ass was visible, moving up and down, and then my fantasy shifted to fucking her tight back hole while she buried her face in Raine’s cunt.

Damn it, there were too many things…and I was making a huge wet spot on the sheets.

“Please, more, faster, harder,” Raine managed to groan, the sound muffled as Maggie fucked her face.

I sped up the tempo, sucking her clit into my mouth, then I held on for dear life as her whole body convulsed beneath me, her orgasm rocking through us both as she screamed in pleasure. Maggie was coming at the same time, her own mouth expertly spewing obscenities as any silver-tongued lawyer would in the throes of ecstasy.

When the aftermath was over, and both ladies lay recovering side by side, I rocked back on my heels and observed them, licking my lips to savor the fading flavor of Raine’s pussy.

It was Raine’s head that popped up first. “Leo…will you fuck me now?”

I looked at Maggie, who nodded. I went to grab a condom, but Raine put her arm on me.

“We talked about it,” she said. “You don’t need one.”

maggie

While my handsome and very-much-aroused husband cooled off and took care of the hot tub cover, I slipped inside the house with Raine. We had a quick chat about limits and STIs.

“We were tested last month,” I told her. “I have it here on my app if you want to see.” I gestured to my phone on the bedside table.

“No, no, I don’t need to see.” Raine waved me off. “I believe you.”

“When were you last tested?” I gave her an expectant look.

“Oh…well…it’s been like a year, but…I haven’t been with anyone since I last got tested.” She smiled. “Sorry, grad students don’t get out much.” She shrugged sheepishly.

“No need to apologize about that. What about birth control?” I ran down the checklist in my head.

“I’m covered there,” she said. “You guys don’t use condoms with other partners?”

“Not if everyone has a recent negative test…”

Her eyes grew wide, so I definitely needed to explain.

“We don’t really do this very often, Raine. It’s been a long time since either of us have had another partner, and, to be honest, we were trying to get pregnant. After we found out I can’t conceive or carry a baby, that’s when we decided to start dating other people again. A lot of the women Leo and I have dated have been older—they’ve had hysterectomies or their tubes are tied. Pregnancy wasn’t a possibility. And…we don’t make a habit of fucking strangers. At least not like we did in our late twenties—whew, that was a—” Seeing her eyes widen again, I opted not to finish that statement. “Anyway, we’ve had committed relationships in the past few years. Fluid-bonded, if you will.”

“Fluid-bonded?” Her curiosity appeared to be piqued if her eyebrow arch was anything to go by.

“Yeah, meaning that we only share bodily fluids amongst our committed partners. It doesn’t mean you can’t have any other partners, it just means you agree to use condoms with them if you aren’t with us,” I explained.

“Oh…”

“Is that something you’d be interested in?” I smiled. I could tell this was all a bit overwhelming for her—a lot to throw at her all at once. And we’d been drinking. We should have discussed this before dinner. I was out of practice.

I shook my head. “You know what? Let’s not decide that now. Let’s wait until next time when we’re all sober and clear-headed. We’ll use condoms tonight, okay? I really do hope this will become a regular thing. I really like you, Raine, and I know Leo does too.”

She blushed, the color extending onto her bare chest. “I’m pretty sober right now, actually. And I like you guys too…”

“We better get up on the bed before he comes back. We wouldn’t want to be disobedient girls, would we?” I winked at her.

“No, ma’am!” She climbed onto the bed and gave me a devilish grin.

That was how we left it when Leo came back in the room from the deck.

And then, when it came time for him to put on a condom and fuck her… she said, “We talked about it. You don’t need one.”

The look that flickered across my husband’s face was one of pure primal passion. “I can’t wait to feel that pussy squeezing me tight.” He tapped the tip of his cock against her clit.

She whimpered and arched her back. “Please?”

“Be a good girl now and take this cock inch by inch,” he groaned as he pushed very slowly inside her until he was balls-deep. A mixture of bliss and need crossed his face as her gasp filled the space between us.

“Fuck her, Leo,” I encouraged him, getting behind him on my knees and wrapping my hands around his chest to play with his nipples. He loved that.

He leaned forward and thrust inside her, pumping a few times as he grabbed her legs and pushed them back for deeper access. “Oh, fuck…you feel so damn good, Raine. I can feel you throbbing.”

I moved from my position, crawling to her until my face was in line with hers. “Are you gonna come on my husband’s cock?”

She gritted out “yes” as I twisted her nipple hard between my fingers, then soothed it with my tongue.

“You’re such a good girl taking his cock like that. How does it feel inside you?”

“So good,” she gasped as he hit a particularly sensitive spot.

I kissed her then, tonguing her mouth in rhythm with Leo’s thrusts as he began to make the noises I knew meant he was getting close to climax. I really wanted Raine to come before he did, so I reached down between their bodies and played with her clit.

Leo rocked back, holding her legs up as he drilled into her, giving me room to work. I lowered my head to her clit, and her hands immediately went into my hair, pushing me closer as she ground her face against me. His cock brushed against my cheek as I sucked on her swollen bud, and it wasn’t long before they were both coming, screaming out into the stillness as they both coated me with their cum.

How fucking beautiful is this moment? Sharing something like this with my man and a beautiful woman I could easily see myself falling in love with.

How fucking beautiful indeed.