The Fallen Ones (Holloway University #1)

40. Damien

Chapter 40

Damien

I picked the lock on Lily’s apartment door just after midnight. We crept into her apartment wearing our gear and Caleb led us to her bedroom down a hallway.

Slowly, he cracked the door open to reveal her lying in bed with only a thin white camisole on and her silk panties. A silver of light from the streetlights cast a glow around her as she laid in slumber, completely unaware of the intruders staring down at her.

I didn’t hesitate. I wanted her more than anything. Slowly, I climbed on the bed with her while Caleb and Jace watched.

With as much care as I had, I slowly inched her panties down her thighs. She mumbled something in her sleep that sounded a lot like Caleb’s name. I paused and looked over at him to see the grin on his face from the cutout in his mask.

Prick.

I could practically hear Jace rolling his eyes.

Turning back to my work, I removed her panties. As carefully as possible, I inched her legs apart.

“Jace,” she mumbled through her sleep. “Miss you.”

I paused and ground my teeth before shooting a glare at Jace who I knew was feeling smug as fuck beneath his mask.

With my cock now out, I ran it up her pussy a few times, making her mumble more, her forehead crinkling. I loved that she was such a heavy sleeper. It made this so much more exciting for me. Something about taking her this way did indescribable things to me.

I was fucked up, but I didn’t give a shit.

I pushed forward and breached her pussy, groaning softly as I did so. I got a few thrusts in before her lashes fluttered. She panicked and tried to buck me off in her sleepy state before I pinned her arms and stared down at her through my mask.

Her breath caught and the fight left her.

Too bad. I liked when she fought me.

I pulled out and pushed back into her wet pussy, earning a soft whimper from her.

Within moments, her hips were bucking up to meet my thrusts. Jace moved forward, his cock out and climbed onto the bed on one side while Caleb got on the other side. There was nowhere for my sweet baby sister to run, but I still hoped she tried.

She parted her lips as she stared up at Jace. He chuckled softly and offered his cock. She wrapped her lips around him, sucking him amid his gravelly groans. I continued my work on her pussy while she reached out and stroked Caleb’s dick.

Full service. Fuck yeah.

Her pussy shuddered before she popped her mouth off Jace’s cock and let out a cry, her orgasm racking through her trembling body. I grinned at my accomplishment as she dampened everything with her spray.

It only made me rail into her harder and faster as the guys tugged her camisole down to reveal her glorious, full tits.

Mesmerized, I watched as they jostled beneath my onslaught. When I couldn’t take it anymore, I came hard, filling her little pussy with my load and groaning my way through it.

Panting, I slowed to a stop, drinking her in as she stared up at me, so disheveled and beautiful I rubbed my chest as a means to calm myself down.

I pulled free of her hot confines and ran my fingers through the mess we’d made before pushing my come back into her. A surge of protectiveness rushed through me. I didn’t want her to see Brandon anymore. I’d been serious earlier when I said I’d kill him. I knew my mind. It wouldn’t affect me in the slightest to take a life. It should have been terrifying to know this, but it only made me want to do it more. I’d end anyone who hurt my little devil.

I shifted aside and let Caleb take my spot. He leaned in and kissed on her. Jace and I watched as she clung to him. Caleb was an interesting guy. He was sweet one moment and vicious the next. I liked that about him. Watching him fuck her near the woods that one night had been amazing. I nearly blew my load being a witness to that. And now.

He was making love to her, not outright fucking. I knew what he was thinking too. It could very well be the last time we do this if we unmasked and she didn’t want us. He wanted to savor it.

So we let him, Jace and I holding back while he did it. I was ready for round two by the time Caleb came with a low moan, matching hers.

He kissed her slowly again before moving off her. I grabbed Lily, making her squeak, and pulled her to straddle me. Jace let out a discontented grunt at my stealing her, but I was doing this for both of us.

I liked fucking her pussy with him.

He soon caught on as I impaled her cunt with my cock and smacked her ass. He shifted so he was behind her.

She stiffened in my hold, clearly not remembering us both stuffing our cocks into her pussy the first night we claimed her.

We’d remedy that.

Jace nudged his cock against her hole where I was already buried.

“It hurts,” she choked out as he worked to fit inside the tight space with me. “N-No. I’ve n-never done this?—”

I gripped her face tightly. “You have,” I growled out at her.

She trembled, her breathing ragged as Jace burrowed deeper.

“You just don’t remember it,” I finished before tangling my fingers in her hair and crushing my lips to hers.

In tandem, we fucked her while Caleb watched, his phone out as he recorded the scene. I liked he was doing that because it would be great spank bank material later if she told us to fuck off. I even considered it as a way to keep her if it came down to it. Women didn’t like their sex tapes released.

I grinned internally at the prospect of keeping her with us that way.

But I really hoped it wouldn’t come to that.

I wanted her to genuinely want me. To want us.

Something about having that would make me feel like a fucking king.

Jace moved faster, and I matched his speed. Her small body jostled between ours as we tore into her pussy. Within moments, she was coming, crying out her pleasure, her head thrown back. Jace claimed her mouth with his at an awkward angle while I squeezed her tits and lifted my head to bite her nipples. It only made her moan into Jace’s mouth as I ravished her full mounds.

My little sister had the best set of tits I’d ever seen on a woman.

Jace’s cock twitched along mine, sending me into orbit. I came with him, both of us filling her little pussy to the brim.

We slowed our movements. Jace released her mouth and kissed her neck. Her shoulder. She hummed a contented tune before he finally pulled out of her.

She needed cleaned, so I rolled her onto her back and stared down at her. Her eyes told me everything she didn’t say.

She wanted this. Us. She cared. It wouldn’t be long until she was as good as ours.

I slowly made my way down her body before I got to her pussy. She stared at me as I kneeled between her legs.

I wanted to taste her and our mess.

So I ran my tongue up her pussy and collected everything before I pushed it back into her.

She moaned beneath the gesture. It must have done something to Jace and Caleb too, because they joined me, all of us vying to eat her pussy and make her come for us one last time.

And it didn’t take long. Three eager tongues on her clit and her pussy had her fisting her sheets and crying out to god and his angels as she came for us again.

We ate like hungry wolves, feasting on the fucking glorious mess between her legs.

Her body shook through the orgasm before she stilled, her breathing ragged. We soon joined her. I pulled her into my arms and held her. She nestled against my body and Jace took her other side while Caleb laid at her feet.

It was perfect. This was what I’d always wanted and didn’t know.

We laid that way for hours, her asleep in my arms. Finally, the clock read five in the morning and I looked to Jace.

“We should go,” he murmured, not having slept a wink. Caleb shifted at the end of the bed and got up.

I didn’t want to leave her, but Jace was right. Now she needed to make a choice.

Jace placed a gentle kiss atop her head before untangling himself and getting out of bed. I followed, but not before brushing my lips against hers and whispering in her ear.

“I love you, baby sister.”

With a tight throat, I got up and looked as Caleb placed a red envelope on her bedside table. We’d typed it out before we got here so she knew what we wanted.

It took everything I had to back away and follow the guys out of her apartment into the night. With no one out on the streets, we were just shadows, headed into the darkness.

Lily was our light though, and I couldn’t wait to come back to her.

I looked to the guys to see the same looks on their faces as was on mine as we removed our masks and got into Jace’s car.

“She’ll be ours,” I murmured.

No one said a word.

Instead, we drove off, hoping for the best.