The Proposition (Hush Hush Duet #2.5)

Chapter 8

Eight

I ’m sitting on James’s lap, naked in the private hot spring tub facing Reece.

It’s like a mini jacuzzi without the jets and just what I needed to recover from the pounding my pussy took. The orgasms were mind blowing and intense, more than I thought possible. Just thinking about Reece’s mouth wrapped around my clit while James’s cock was inside me makes me ache to be touched again.

The night isn’t over. I secretly needed a break and was glad James suggested one. We’ve been soaking in the warm water for over thirty minutes now.

“I didn’t know you liked men,” I say to Reece, intrigued from earlier.

He shrugs one shoulder casually. “I don’t broadcast that I’m bisexual. If it happens, it happens. I enjoy having sex with both men and women. The experience is completely different.”

Under the water, James cups my pussy and tugs me to him. He presses the tip of his finger against my opening. My legs spread on their own accord, and his cock bounces lightly against my back from the gravity of the water.

“Do you think you’ll ever settle down and get married?” I ask.

“No,” he says quickly, shaking his head. “Unless I can be in an open relationship, the answer is no. Never.”

James’s laugh vibrates against my back. “Reece is going to be a bachelor his whole life.” He’s teasing my entrance with his fingers, stroking over my swollen lips.

Reece’s boyish grin is contagious. He runs his fingers through his damp hair, the curls tight at the ends. “I’m okay with that. I like my freedom,” he says. “Most people aren’t comfortable in their own presence. I welcome the solitude. Peace and silence are a wonderful thing.”

I raise my champagne glass. “Good for you for knowing what you want. Half the world still doesn’t know, and their time is running out.”

James slides a finger into my pussy, and I nearly choke in the middle of swallowing my champagne. I hook my legs around his calves.

“You guys aren’t playing without me, are you?” Reece says, swimming toward us.

My nipples pucker in anticipation. James holds out my breast as an offering to Reece. I inhale a small breath, a new wave of desire falling over me.

“Your tits are bigger than I remember,” Reece says, stopping in front of me.

He smushes them together then leans down and takes one into his mouth, twirling his tongue around the pink part in a way that, if I were standing, would make my knees shake. He pulls back with a pop, the tip of his tongue lingering on the tip of my nipple.

James takes one of Reece’s wrists and pulls it underwater. A moan pushes its way from me as both their fingers slide into my pussy.

“Fuck,” I mumble inwardly. The thought is just as hot as the real thing. They rub the walls of my pussy, manipulating me wider. “That feels incredible,” I whisper.

James takes my glass and places it on the ledge. He slips his hand underwater again. This time he goes slow. “I propose an idea.”

A thrill of excitement moves through me. Valentina never turns down an offer. “What is it?”

“What if we both fucked you tonight.” He pauses. “And I don’t mean one in the back and one in the front.”

My brows draw together at what he’s implying. “You mean…”

“Fuck your pussy. Together. Both of our cocks at the same time.”

“Yes,” Reece groans out. “Hell, yes.”

His request renders me speechless. James doesn’t exactly have a pencil dick, and neither does Reece. If they were smaller I’d consider it, but I don’t think both could fit inside me. Some days I walk bowlegged because of James and his cock. Now he wants to stuff two inside me?

“I don’t think you guys will fit,” I say, dead serious. “I’m not sure I even want to test it out. I’m afraid I’ll rip from hole to hole.”

“We’ll fit. I’ve done it before. It’s just a muscle. It stretches. If a woman can birth a ten-pound baby, you can fit two cocks,” Reece states.

I can’t control the laugh that flies out of me. I giggle so hard that tears form in the corners of my eyes. I mean, I guess he’s not wrong and that it is possible.

“What do you say, sweetheart? You want us to both fuck you?”

Yes is my first thought.

James presses on my clit, and I suck in a deep breath of air into my lungs. I’m not opposed to it, but the idea of it does leave me with apprehension from the mechanics of it.

“How…and where… What positions? Not in the water, right?”

“Instead of telling you, why don’t we show you?” James suggests.

Something about that makes me come alive with burning need. My hips rear back into James’s lap. Their joined fingers bring me to the edge, and euphoria takes over. I’ve had so many orgasms already, I’ve lost count.

We get out of the water and dry off. Reece and James talk about how they want to make this work, where we’ll be and what we’ll need. Listening, I grab the bottle of lube I packed.

“We can do it standing where we both hold her body up, or we can do it in bed sort of like missionary.”

“I think the bed would be easier. That way I won’t feel like I’m going to slip,” I say.

I also think with both dicks inside me while standing makes it easier to rip, which is what I’m secretly afraid of.

“We won’t drop you,” James says quickly.

I smile at him. “I know, but it just seems like so much more work.”

“Bed it is,” Reece says. “Aubrey, get on top of James. Chest to chest. You guys do your thing, and then I’ll join. Don’t come, Aubrey.”

Reece is speaking when it dawns on me he hasn’t seen James and me have sex before. James has watched me with Reece, but not the other way around. Need drips down my inner thigh at the thought of being watched with my husband. Taking one last sip of the mixed drink James gave me earlier, I place the glass down on the counter and then climb onto the bed.

“I imagine I won’t be able to have much more sex after this, so make it worth it,” I tell them.

James is on his back in a matter of seconds. I straddle his hips and take his cock in one long thrust.

Ah, feels like home.

We moan in unison, my eyes closing shut. Our bodies click together too perfectly, and my heart rejoices. I stay upright as he slowly fucks me, showing me who ultimately owns my body and soul. James doesn’t just get Valentina. He gets both of us.

“Her pussy is soft and warm. Now is the time to join in,” James suggests to Reece then looks at me. “Come here and kiss me.”