The Very Naughty List

33. Hailey

33

HAILEY

Goosebumps race across my skin at Reid’s order. I strip everything but my panties off quickly and stand there nearly naked for a second, reveling in the way three pairs of eyes rake me like a pride of lions waiting to pounce.

“Look down, trouble,” Reid tells me, his voice still low and commanding.

I do what he says without question, and my eyes widen at the sight of a pair of gorgeous Louboutin heels set beside the door. I’ve never seen them before in my life, and it strikes me in a rush that the guys must’ve bought them—for me.

“Put them on,” Sebastian says, arching a brow.

Biting my lip and resting a hand against the wall to steady myself, I slip one foot and then the other into the beautiful stilettos, amazed at how perfectly they hug my feet. The men got the exact right size.

“Good. Now get on your knees,” Reid says firmly, and although my breath hitches, I’m not about to disobey. I sink down to them slowly, and he smiles at me when I’m done. “Good girl. Now crawl to us.”

Again, my skin surges to life with a tingling heat. I gingerly put both hands on the floor, then move one in front of the other, crawling across the living room toward the three of them.

“Stop,” Reid barks, and I obey instantly. “Eyes up here. Unless I tell you otherwise.”

I tilt my chin up to lock eyes with him and nod as a shiver tingles down the length of my spine. He knows exactly what to say and what to do to push my submissive buttons, to get me right into that space where I know he’s in control and I can just let go and feel .

And I love it.

“Goddamn, you look so fucking good on your knees,” Reid says as he admires me. He beckons me forward with two fingers, and I obediently start crawling toward them again, adding a slink to my movements as my hips sway back and forth. “Fuck, you love being shared by us, don’t you?”

I nod without breaking eye contact, my heart hammering against my ribs.

“Yes,” I whisper as I reach the three of them and come to a stop in front of Reid, who’s at the center. “I love it more than anything.”

“Of course you do. Because you’re a good little slut for us, aren’t you?” he asks, his voice a low rasp. “Just for us.”

“Yes,” I repeat with more emphasis, and Reid’s jaw clenches as he unzips his pants and reaches inside to retrieve his hard, leaking cock. He grips the base, giving it a squeeze, and my clit throbs.

“Then why don’t you show us just what a filthy, perfect girl you are?”

“Mm,” I moan and rise up off my hands to take his cock in one of them, guiding it into my mouth. Nick chuckles hoarsely as he shoves his pants down as well, palming and stroking his cock.

“Look how fucking hungry she is for it,” he murmurs. “Even after I got her off at the parade.”

“Like I said, she needs all of us. Because you’re a greedy little thing, aren’t you, trouble?” Reid asks as my lips glide across the swollen shaft of his cock. All I can do is groan eagerly around him. “Fuck yeah, you are. Tap if it’s too much.”

With that warning, he grabs my head and thrusts his cock hard and fast in and out of my mouth, almost making me gag. But I relax the back of my throat, suppressing my gag reflex as I stare up at him through my lashes, heat coursing through my veins at the rough way he’s using me.

He slides in and out several more times before finally dragging me off his cock, both of us breathing hard. His shaft is slick and shiny with my saliva, the vein running along the top pulsing angrily. He’s so hard it looks almost painful, but instead of pressing back inside my mouth, he smiles down at me, tipping his chin toward his brothers.

“I know what you need,” he tells me softly. “So take it, trouble. Suck them both, just like you want to. Let us share you, the way we fucking love to.”

A flood of wetness soaks my panties, and I lunge for Nick first, taking him all the way down to the base.

“Fuck,” he curses, his spine curling a bit as his cock pulses against my tongue. He grips the back of my skull, holding me in place until I’m coughing and sputtering on him, then finally lets me go.

I come up gasping, dragging in a deep lungful of air before sliding back down his length. My nose brushes against the hair at the base of his cock as I deep throat him over and over, moaning around him.

By the time I finally pull away, I feel like my entire body is flushed with arousal. I switch over to Sebastian and moan at the familiar, metallic taste of his piercings as they glide over my tongue. But all I can think about, hunger for, is to feel them inside my aching, soaked pussy instead.

“Such a good girl,” Reid praises as he and Nick watch. “Open wide for him.”

The three of them take turns with my mouth, each man fucking my face until he’s right up to the edge before pulling me off his shaft and passing me to the next one. The wet, sloppy sounds of my mouth on their cocks and their hands stroking themselves fill the room, and I close my eyes as Nick palms the back of my head, lost in a fantasy of the three of them coating my face in their cum at the same time.

Then Nick’s hand tightens on my hair as he tugs me off his cock, sending tingles spreading across my scalp.

“Get up,” he orders, pulling me up to my feet so he can look me in the eye. His dark blue irises are on fire with desire. I reach for his cock to stroke it, but he brushes my hand away, smirking as he shakes his head. “No more of that, songbird. It’s your turn. Take off your panties, then go to the window and brace your hands on the glass.”

“Yes, sir,” I say, my voice breathy.

He drops my hair, leaving behind a tingle like an ice cube on bare skin, and I kick off my soaked panties and stride over to the window, my new high heels clicking across the floor. I can’t see their faces, but I feel their gazes burning into my back, watching my every move.

I know they can see how wet I am from the way they’ve been using me. I feel it, hot and slick between my legs, with every step I take. My clit is throbbing with arousal, so much that I feel like I could come just from the friction of walking like this.

But I reach the window before that happens, so I bend slightly to rest my hands on the glass and jut my ass out at the three of them. Without glancing over my shoulder, I slip a hand between my legs, intending to finger myself and really give them a show, but this time, Reid’s hand pushes it away. A second later, I cry out when his palm collides with my ass cheek.

“Nice try.” He chuckles roughly. “I love the initiative, trouble. But that’s for my brothers and me to do.”

“Then what are you waiting for?” I shoot back, being a brat just because I know it will bring out his dominant side even more. “This pussy isn’t going to fuck itself.”

He chuckles darkly. “Oh, baby. You have no idea what you’re in for. Nick, you want to take her first? You’re the one who got her all worked up and needy at the parade.”

“With pleasure,” Nick rumbles, stepping closer. “We’re gonna make your whole body sing, songbird.”

Without warning, he grips my hips and slides his cock into me, forcing my mouth open and my body up against the window. He grabs me by the neck, gripping just tightly enough to make my pulse race without coming close to cutting off my air, and my forehead rests against the window pane. He’s not holding anything back, and with each powerful thrust into me, my breath spills out and fogs the window.

“Fuck, look at you taking him like a champ,” Reid groans. “Is this what you were wishing for while he made you come on that float? Is this what you wanted?”

I nod, my cheek pressed against the window, but he shakes his head.

“Use your words, trouble.”

“Yes! Fuck, yes!”

Satisfaction flashes through his eyes where he stands beside us, and he rests his fingers on my collarbone, then drags them down my body, teasing my nipples lightly before moving lower to find my clit. With his eyes locked on mine, he circles it hard and fast, and I cry out, my eyes squeezing shut.

“There you go,” Sebastian murmurs, moving in on my other side and joining Reid in touching me. “Scream for us. Scream so loud that all of Chestnut Hill will hear you.”

“Fuck,” I gasp, my heart racing in my ears and almost drowning out the wet, slapping sounds of Nick fucking me like a wild man.

“That’s not very ladylike, trouble,” Reid scolds in a deep voice, then draws back and gives my clit a light slap.

“Oh my god!” I gasp. The sensation combined with Nick’s cock pounding into me, is almost overwhelming. My legs start to tremble as the rest of my body tenses, and stars dance in the edges of my vision as my orgasm builds closer and closer to the crest. There’s no way I could hold it back even if I wanted.

Reid’s intense gaze shifts to Nick. “She’s going to come. Fuck her harder, just the way she likes it.”

Nick grunts and nods, then turns up the intensity even further. He’s slamming so hard and fast into me now that I’m sliding up the glass, but all I can focus on is the wave of pleasure welling inside me.

I take one last desperate breath and hold it for several seconds as I hurtle into an orgasm, my body trembling underneath Nick’s thrusts and Reid’s palm as he continues working my clit. When the breath I’ve been holding comes shuddering out of me, I feel like my soul goes rushing out alongside it for a moment. Then I snap back into my body as all my senses come roaring back, and I realize I’ve been screaming the whole time.

“I told you we’d make you sing,” Nick grunts as he continues fucking me mercilessly, but his words barely pierce through the blood rushing in my ears. When I finally start to come down from the high, he slows down enough that he can lower his lips to my ear. “Before I fill you up, do you want my brothers to fuck you like this too?”

A lightning bolt of heat streaks down my spine.

“No,” I rasp, and Nick’s thrusts stutter. Reid’s brows jerk upward, surprise flashing through his expression. It brings a grin to my face, and I chew my lip as I stare back at him, working up the nerve to ask for what I need most right now.

“I want all three of you to fuck me,” I breathe.

Reid smirks, his features relaxing as he keeps toying with my clit, bringing out a few aftershocks from my climax. “I had a feeling you’d say that. Do you want me or Sebastian next?”

“Neither. I want all three of you… at the same time.”

His eyes widen, and his hand freezes on my clit. Nick chuckles behind me as Sebastian lets out a rough groan. The temperature in the room seems to gradually climb with each heavy second that passes, as all three of them absorb my words.

Finally, Reid rests the fingers of his free hand on my chin. “Are you sure you know what you’re asking for?”

“As sure as I’ve ever been.”

“Then say it. Tell us exactly what you want and how you want it.”

Keeping my palms braced on the window, I glance over at Sebastian, who’s standing on my other side. “I want you to fuck me, all at the same time. I want a cock in all three of my holes. One in my mouth,” I breathe, holding Sebastian’s gaze so that he gets the message. Then I crane my neck to meet Nick’s eyes. “One in my pussy.” Finally, I look back to Reid. “And one in my ass.”

All three of them groan at once, making me shudder. Without a word, Sebastian nods and disappears up the stairs, and Nick pulls out of me slowly before lifting me up by my legs to carry me to the spot in front of the fireplace with Reid right behind us. Nick gently lays me down on the floor on my back, sprawled out in front of them, and Sebastian returns a second later carrying a bottle of lube.

Holy shit. We’re really doing this.

My stomach flutters with anticipation as the three of them strip off their remaining clothes and join me on the floor, their hands and mouths exploring every inch of my body and lighting me up with desire all over again.

Nick lies on the floor beside me, still rock hard.

“Ride him,” Reid breathes into my ear as he kisses my neck, so I spin onto my hands and knees, still in my heels, and climb on top of Nick, guiding his cock back into me.

“Fuck,” Nick groans as his hands find my hips and his cock disappears up to the hilt.

“Good. Now lean forward,” Reid instructs, pressing gently on the small of my back.

I drop both hands on either side of Nick’s head to brace myself and present my ass to him. Reid kneels behind me, his chest pressed against my back, and teases my asshole with his fingers. My breath catches at the unfamiliar sensation, my body clenching involuntarily.

“Breathe deep now, trouble,” he tells me, his voice soothing. “Nice and deep, in and out.”

I do as I’m told, and Reid runs his fingers around and across my hole, slowly getting me used to the feeling of it and relaxing me while he kisses my neck and shoulder. Sebastian stands in front of me, his pierced cock bobbing in front of my face, and pops open the bottle of lube. Reid reaches out, and Sebastian turns the bottle over to drizzle out a healthy amount into Reid’s palm. Reid works it into his fingers to warm it up.

“Are you ready?” he asks as he lowers his hand back to my ass.

“Fuck yes,” I whimper, but my breath still catches when his slick fingers find my asshole again. My pussy clamps around Nick’s cock, pulling a groan out of him, but it’s nothing compared to how tightly I squeeze him when one of Reid’s knuckles slips past the tight ring of muscles.

“Goddamn, you’re gonna make me come like this,” Nick groans as my pussy spasms around him.

“You’re gonna make me come first,” I say, shaking my head a little jerkily. I can feel sensations building inside me, pleasure already burning so hot in my veins that I know it won’t take long.

Hunger flashes in his irises, and his fingers dig into my hips like he can’t wait to start fucking me again. That makes two of us.

“That’s one finger,” Reid says as he pushes it all the way into me, then starts slowly dragging it back out. Both my holes squeeze, and I can’t fight the groan that bubbles at the back of my throat. “Keep breathing. I’m going to work another finger in.”

I take another deep, long inhale, and on the exhale, two of Reid’s fingers start pushing against my hole, making my toes curl. The stretching feels amazing, and with Nick’s firm cock still buried in me, it’s already almost enough to make me come. But Reid applies more pressure, shoving his thick fingers into me and opening me up more, and I know I’m going to lose it.

“Fuck, I can’t hold it,” I whimper and hold on to Nick’s shoulders as another orgasm tears through me. Reid’s fingers fuck me faster, working me through it as Nick thrusts up into me and I soak his cock in response.

“Good girl. Give in to it,” Reid encourages, twisting his fingers up to the knuckle inside me and making me cry out as wave after wave of pleasure pulses through me. I fall forward onto Nick, my elbows and wrists resting on his chest, and Reid chuckles. “I think you’re ready for the real deal now.”

“Shit,” I whisper as the last of the orgasm works its way out of me. But Sebastian tips my head up by my chin, his dribbling cock beckoning me, and I take it into my mouth without a second thought, working his piercings with my tongue.

“Oh, she’s definitely ready,” he says with a laugh as he passes Reid the bottle of lube. I hear the cap pop and the wet crackle as Reid coats his cock with it. His greased cock head finds my hole, teasing it, and I moan around Sebastian’s cock.

“Deep breaths now, trouble. Just like before,” Reid says, stroking my lower back as he starts pushing into me. My eyes flutter shut, but I keep breathing and bobbing on Sebastian as Reid stretches me out. His head presses past the tight ring of muscles a few seconds later, and the breath leaves my lungs, my cry muffled around Sebastian’s shaft.

It’s a good thing I have Sebastian’s cock in my mouth to keep me quiet, otherwise the whole neighborhood would hear me screaming in pleasure.

“Is that okay?” Reid asks, pausing. “How does it feel, trouble?”

I draw back a little so that I can speak, my voice raspy. “It feels… oh god, it’s so much. But I need… I need more.”

“That’s our girl.”

Reid keeps working his way inside, murmuring praise and encouragement as he tells me to open for him, to let him in, telling me he knows I can do it. Nick lies still to give me the chance to adjust, and after what feels like a long time, I hear Reid exhale in pleasure when the base of his cock meets my body.

“It’s in,” he rasps. “You’re taking all of me. All of us . Are you all right?”

A moan is all I can manage to answer with, and the three of them chuckle. Reid stays still for a few moments before he starts to very slowly drag his cock out of me, and I feel like I might pass out from the sheer amount of pleasure rushing to my brain. But it’s nothing compared to the way every nerve ending in my body lights up when he starts driving back into me again.

“Fuck!” I hiss, Sebastian’s cock falling out of my mouth. But he lifts me by the chin and presses back in, muffling the rest of my noises.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it, shortcake?” he asks as I hollow my cheeks around him.

And he’s so fucking right about that. This is every one of my filthiest fantasies come to life.

I’ve forgotten how to speak, all rational thought replaced by the wavelike rhythm of the three of their cocks sliding in and out of me in alternating movements, completely in sync. Sebastian slides down my throat while Reid thrusts into my ass and Nick draws out of my pussy.

It’s fucking ecstasy. The men murmur filthy things to me, punctuating their words with snaps of their hips, filling me up even more as the tempo increases.

Sebastian’s cock leaks precum onto my tongue, flooding my senses with the salty tang of him, and I hum in delight. His head drops back while his hands wrap around the back of my neck, holding me still so he can use my mouth at his own pace.

I’m completely lost in the thrill of it all—until somewhere across the room, my phone starts ringing in the clothes I left behind. I ignore it, too lost in the moment to care. But almost as soon as it stops ringing, it starts up again.

“Fuck,” Sebastian mutters, his teeth bared with annoyance. “Hang on.”

He takes his cock from my mouth and then strides quickly over to my pile of clothes to fish my phone out. He stares at the screen for a moment, a look I can’t quite read passing across his face.

Then he shocks the hell out of me by swiping across the screen to answer.

“Oh, hi, Dylan,” he says, bringing the phone to his ear. “Sorry, Hailey’s a little preoccupied and can’t come to the phone right now.”