The Very Naughty List

44. Hailey

44

HAILEY

We burst through the front door of the Cooper brothers’ house, our hands and mouths all over each other in a whirlwind as we tear off our clothes, leaving a trail halfway up the stairs. The men pass me between them so often and quickly that I lose track of who I’m kissing, but it doesn’t matter. I can’t get enough of all three of them, of their hard bodies and firm hands on me.

But when Nick kneels in front of me halfway up the stairs, pressing my back against the banister, I realize there’s no way we’re making it to the bedroom before the real fun begins.

And that’s just fine with me.

He drags his beard across my pussy, teasing me and making my skin flash with goosebumps, while Reid takes me by the chin and pulls me in for a deep, powerful kiss, and Sebastian’s mouth closes around one of my nipples. He drags the tip of his tongue in circles a few times, then gently clamps down on my nipple with his teeth to hold it in place so he can flick his tongue against it.

“Fuck,” I moan into Reid’s mouth as Nick’s tongue explores my pussy at the same time.

I feel like I could totally lose myself in the three of them. There’s so much arousal, so much raw passion, sparking between the four of us that it lights up my nerves in all the best ways.

But it’s hotter than ever now—because it’s not just about sex anymore. We’re beyond that, beyond pretending this is just a simple hookup. There’s meaning to it, and the way each of them is working me over makes that crystal clear. They care about me, so much more than I ever realized, and that makes me feel like the luckiest girl in the world. Plenty of women would kill for this kind of connection with one man, let alone three.

“Everything okay?” Reid asks when our mouths finally part, his eyes searching mine.

“Flawless.”

“Just like you,” he says with a warm smile, and I lunge to kiss him again, basking in the feeling of his mouth on mine, Sebastian’s teeth on my nipples, and Nick’s tongue on my pussy.

But Nick catches me off guard when he hoists both of my legs up onto his shoulders with my back braced against the banister, suspending me in space. With a groan, he buries his face deeper between my legs, his tongue dragging over every inch of me. My head falls back, and Reid palms the nape of my neck, supporting me as he holds my gaze intently.

“I love this look on your face. When you’re lost in the feelings my brothers give you,” he says as Sebastian moves up to my neck, kissing it and dragging a moan out of me.

“It’s one of the most beautiful sights I’ve ever seen,” Sebastian agrees, his voice barely more than a whisper in my ear.

I mewl and shudder beneath their touch, trying my best to hold off my climax a little longer as Nick devours me. It’s a good thing he’s holding me up with his broad shoulders, because if I were still standing, I think my knees might give out.

“You know what else I love? I fucking love how sensitive you are, trouble,” Reid says, his eyes burning as his fingers trail down my chest toward my clit. He brushes a fingertip against it, lighting me up from the inside, and smirks at the reaction it draws out of me. “God, I can’t wait to get you to bed.”

“I can’t wait either. So why should we?” I whisper and swing one leg off Nick’s shoulder, catching him by surprise. My heart races as I turn around, resting my stomach against the banister and leaning over it a bit to expose my ass and pussy to them all.

“Fuck,” Reid growls and claps a hand against one of my ass cheeks, giving me an intensely pleasurable sting.

Nick takes a swipe at my pussy with his tongue from behind before standing up and teasing my entrance with his cock head. Then he pushes inside. I grip the banister and bite my lip as I adjust, and Nick only gives me a few seconds to catch my breath before he starts thrusting.

“You take me so well,” Nick grunts. “I’ll never get tired of this. Fucking never .”

My legs shake with each thrust, and Reid and Sebastian watch their brother fuck my brains out until their control finally snaps.

“My turn.” Reid steps closer, nudging Nick’s shoulder.

Nick groans and pulls out, and Reid takes his place immediately. He grips a fistful of my hair tightly, using it to gently pull my head backward as he teases my entrance with his cock.

“Ready for more?” he asks.

“God, yes. Fuck me. All of you.”

It’s been hell waiting for them all to feel comfortable enough to fuck me again since the crash, and the way that Reid is manhandling me right now has opened the floodgates of my arousal. With his cock notched against me, I pitch my hips backward and feel him slide inside where he belongs until his body meets mine.

“Mm, so greedy.” He chuckles. “Fine. I’ll give you what you want, my beautiful little brat.”

With that, he draws back slowly, then slams all the way back inside. I cry out, and the banister squeaks from the force.

“Look how wet she is already. It’s been a long wait, huh, shortcake?” Sebastian asks with a sympathetic look as he tilts my chin up with his hand to face him. “Don’t worry. We’ll make it worth it.”

I nod and rock backward again to meet Reid’s next thrust. His cock hits my g-spot, making me moan, and Sebastian smiles and nods encouragingly.

“There you go. Take what you need. But make sure you save some of that energy for me.”

Reid pounds into me several more times, each stroke hard and demanding, then abruptly pulls out and slaps my ass again before he steps back to make room for Sebastian. “Your turn.”

Sebastian’s cock rests against my stinging ass, and the coldness of his metal piercings, along with the thought of getting them back inside me, makes a shiver run through me. I’m expecting him to take me just like his brothers did, but instead, he spins me by the hips to face him.

“That’s better,” he murmurs, his eyes gleaming with desire. “I want to see your beautiful face when I fuck you.”

He lifts me up, resting my ass against the banister, and I lock my legs around his waist and my arms around his neck. He presses a kiss to my lips, his fingers digging into my thighs.

“There you go. Let me take care of you.”

He begins pressing into me, his pierced length stretching me and making it difficult to concentrate on anything else as I silently count each stud. He never takes his blue-green eyes off my face, watching each little shift in my expression, until he’s all the way inside me. Then he kisses me again.

“Fuck, baby. You look so good when you’re taking my cock. I fucking love the way I can read it all on your face.”

I don’t have the mental bandwidth for words right now, so in response, I attack his lips with my own. He growls, his tongue sliding against mine, and lifts me farther up the banister to let me fall back down on his cock. I gasp into his mouth when our bodies meet.

“That’s it. Get fucking loud for me,” he growls and does it again, pulling a shuddering moan out of me. His brothers stand on either side of him, stroking themselves and watching with expressions that are nearly feral with lust.

It’s almost too much to take, and Sebastian must be able to sense how close I’m getting, because he hoists me off the banister after another moment. Without ever pulling out of me, he carries me up the rest of the stairs toward my bedroom, with Nick and Reid right behind him.

Every step Sebastian takes moves him in and out of me a little, inching me closer and closer to my orgasm, and I’m sure I’m going to lose it before we get to the bed—but somehow, I’m able to fight it back.

Sebastian climbs onto the bed with me still clinging to him, then lays me back on the pillows and gently pulls out to hover over me, admiring my spread legs. My hand instinctively reaches for my clit, but Reid catches me by the wrist and shakes his head.

“Uh uh, baby. Not so fast.” He turns to Sebastian. “Lie down.” Sebastian flops down next to me on his back, and Reid’s eyes drift back to mine. “Get on top of him.”

I heard him loud and clear, but my arousal-addled brain is slow to respond, so he and Nick both lift me up like I weigh nothing. I’m expecting them to lower me down onto their brother’s cock, but instead, they move me higher until my pussy is hovering over his face, then set my knees down on the mattress.

“Good.” Reid nods in satisfaction. “Now grab the headboard.”

“Why?” I ask breathlessly.

“Because it’ll give you something to hold yourself steady while you ride my brother’s face.”

My body hums at his words, even as my stomach flutters with nerves. This is another one of the few remaining things on my bucket list, and Reid knows it. We’ve done way more adventurous stuff than this already, so it’s not like I have anything to be nervous about. But still, I can’t help but be anxious.

“Are you sure?” I ask, glancing down at Sebastian’s face where he looks up at me from between my legs. “I won’t suffocate you?”

“I wouldn’t give a shit if you did, shortcake,” he answers with a chuckle. “Being smothered by your pussy is literally my dream way to die.”

That makes me laugh, and I finally work up the courage to nod. “Okay.”

I grip the headboard like Reid told me to and shift my weight on my knees, which are resting on either side of Sebastian’s head.

“Mm, fuck yes. There, just like that.” Sebastian hums in approval, reaching around to grip my ass cheeks and using that hold to pull me closer to him. His tongue darts out to lick my clit, making me jump, and he chuckles. “Don’t be afraid to put your whole weight down on me. Reid told you to ride me, and that’s what I need you to do. I want to bury my face between these gorgeous thighs and never come up for air.”

His words burn away any reservations I still have. I lower my pussy down against his waiting tongue, rocking backward and forward against him, and he groans in approval. My nails dig into the headboard because it feels amazing , way better than I thought it would when Reid first told me what to do.

Sebastian holds me in place for a moment to work his tongue inside me, then gently pats my ass to encourage me. Without a word, I know exactly what he wants me to do, so I start bouncing up and down on his thick, muscular tongue like it’s his cock instead.

“Fuck yeah, ride his face,” Nick says, leaning closer to watch Sebastian’s tongue driving in and out of me as he strokes himself. “How’s she taste, Seb?”

“As sweet as ever,” Sebastian’s muffled voice answers as his tongue works me over. “So fucking good.”

Reid’s hand reaches for one of my stiffened nipples and gives it a sharp twist, making me cry out and clamp down on Sebastian’s tongue.

“I know you’ve been waiting a long time for this, trouble. I bet you’re getting close already, aren’t you, dirty girl?”

“Yes,” I breathe because it’s all I can manage and he’s one thousand percent right.

Between this and the three of them sharing me on the stairs after days of not being able to have sex with them, I’m teetering on a knife’s edge, and even the slightest sensation could send me hurtling over it.

But I don’t want them to stop.

“So if I did this, would it be too much?” Reid asks as he reaches with his free hand for my clit. He slaps it lightly before pinching it, and my breathing turns ragged.

“Oh my god,” I groan, bouncing harder on Sebastian’s tongue.

Reid chuckles. “I’ll take that as a yes. Why don’t you help me out here, Nick? Let’s see how far we can push her. I want to know just how much our girl can take.”

“Thought you’d never ask,” Nick says, his smirk clear behind his beard.

He and Reid each take charge of one of my nipples, pinching and twisting them. My head falls back, and my eyes start to water from the sheer sensation of it all. When both their hands also find my clit and their rough, calloused fingers take turns working it while Sebastian stiffens his tongue and drives it in and out of me, I know I’m lost.

“That’s right,” Reid urges, his voice low. “Fall apart for us, trouble. We’ve got you. I want to see you fucking lose it.”

As if in response to his command, I come hard, screaming. My hands grip the headboard so hard that it hurts. But that hold is the only thing keeping me grounded, the only thing stopping me from completely leaving my body. The three of them don’t stop working over my body, not until the final shockwaves fade away and the spell breaks.

“Holy shit,” I gasp, shuddering each time Sebastian’s tongue laps against me, cleaning up every bit of the mess I’ve made.

Reid and Nick help me climb off their brother’s face, and I melt onto the mattress, exhausted and glowing. Sebastian’s head rolls to face mine, his chin still glistening with my arousal.

“That was absolutely fucking perfect,” he murmurs and kisses me, his lips slick and sweet with my taste.

A fresh wave of desire surges inside me as Nick lifts one of my arms in both hands. He turns it to expose the tender skin on the underside and drags his lips and beard down the length of my limb until he reaches my wrist.

“Everything about her is perfect. Every. Single. Goddamned. Thing,” he says, kissing my wrist between each word before reaching for my other arm and kissing that wrist too.

“One more bucket list item down,” Reid says as he brushes my hair out of my face. “But there’s at least one more I think we can take care of.”

My heart skips a beat at the suggestion, and my eyes snap to his. “What are you going to do?”

His smile deepens, and he shares a look with his brothers before nodding at me. “Let’s just keep it a surprise. It’s more fun that way, don’t you think?”

He leaves me hanging and disappears out of the room for a few seconds. I have no idea what’s about to happen until he returns with a blindfold dangling from one finger and a few feet of rope thrown over his shoulder.

“Where did you…?”

He shrugs. “After I read your bucket list, I had a feeling we might be needing some supplies, so I picked some up. I like to be prepared.”

My skin erupts in goosebumps as Nick and Sebastian kneel on either side of me, each man holding one of my arms in their hands. They position me just how they want me while Reid approaches and fits the blindfold over my eyes, then loops the rope around each of my wrists and ties them both to the bed posts.

“Is everything okay?” Sebastian asks, temporarily lifting the blindfold so I can see his face. “The ropes aren’t too tight?”

“No, they’re fine.”

“Good.” He drops the blindfold again and checks the tie in the back. “Can you see anything through this?”

I shake my head, and the bed creaks as someone climbs off the mattress. A second later, I jump when a hand meets my rib cage and fingers tickle down it like a set of piano keys.

“She’s telling the truth,” Sebastian informs Reid and Nick, so it must have been him testing me.

“Oh, this is gonna be fun,” Nick says, and I can hear the smile in his voice. It makes my nipples harden.

Tied up and blindfolded like this, I’m completely at their mercy. I won’t know what’s coming or from where, who’s touching or fucking me. They can do whatever they want, and all I can do is lie back and enjoy the ride.

God, this is even better than my fantasies. Because it’s with all of them.

The bed creaks as someone kneels on my right side, and I hold my breath in anticipation.

“If it’s ever too much, just say so, and we’ll stop, okay?” Reid asks. I nod quickly, although I don’t see that happening. “Good girl.”

His hand runs through my hair several times, relaxing me, and a second later, I jump again when I feel something brush against my lips.

I part them instinctively and feel Reid’s hard cock slip inside. It’s warm and firm, leaking salty pre-cum on my tongue, and I hum at the taste of it.

“Fuck, that’s hot,” Reid groans quietly as I work my tongue across the underside of his shaft and then circle his crown.

A hand finds my thigh and trails downward, all the way to my foot, but I can’t tell whose it is, not even when it starts massaging the sole. I groan around Reid’s cock, and he gently rocks his hips forward and back, guiding his length in and out of my mouth.

“Let’s play a little game,” he says as he continues fucking my mouth. “A guessing game. We’re going to take turns touching you or fucking you, and you’re going to try to figure out who it is.”

I draw back a little, popping off his shaft to speak. “What if I get it wrong?”

He just chuckles in response, his fingers tracing the line of my jaw. Then he kisses me before the mattress shifts as he moves to one side. I shiver as the hands massaging my foot set it gently back on the bed, and the mystery man moves upward over me.

A cock head presses against my entrance, and my hips instinctively rise to meet it.

Everything feels more powerful like this. Maybe it’s because I can’t see, so my body is trying to compensate, but I swear I can feel each electric little movement as whoever it is starts to press inside me, opening me up. I can’t feel any piercings, so it’s safe to rule out Sebastian.

“Sebastian?” I guess in a whisper.

“Wrong,” Reid answers for whoever is fucking me, and when I open my mouth, another cock slides between my lips. He’s not gentle, hitting the back of my throat on the first thrust, and when I gag a little, he pulls back and strokes my cheek. “Too rough?”

“Not rough enough,” I gasp back, my body buzzing.

Reid chuckles. “That’s our filthy girl. Every time you get it wrong, you’ll pay for it.”

“Fuck,” I whimper.

“Oh, trust me, there will be fucking,” he promises, and whoever’s inside me takes a hard thrust out and in, making my breath catch in my throat.

God. If this is the punishment, I can’t wait to find out what the reward is .

Honestly, I can’t believe how much both ideas turn me on. I never thought I’d get to do even half of the things on my bucket list, and there’s no one I’d rather be doing something like this with than the three of them. There’s no one else I’d ever trust even remotely enough to make myself this vulnerable with, mentally or physically.

Do they have any idea how much this means to me?

“Guess again,” Reid orders. It wasn’t him, and it can’t be Sebastian, so that only leaves one other option.

“Nick?”

Nick groans in confirmation and takes several deep, needy strokes into me. My hands twist and writhe against the ropes holding them in place, and I try to wrap my legs around him to keep him going, but he abruptly stops and pulls out, leaving me panting and begging for more.

“Please, keep going. Please .”

“That was only the first round, songbird,” Nick says over the shuffling of the three of them moving around the bed, taking different positions. “You’re gonna have to work harder than that to get your reward.”

Several seconds pass without any of them talking or touching me, and my head instinctively tosses side to side, hopelessly trying to get some sense of what’s happening or coming next. There’s a hunger inside me only they can sate, and every second that passes without one of them fucking me drives me crazier.

“Someone fucking touch me,” I whine, tugging against the ropes desperately and making the headboard creak a bit. As if on command, a hot mouth lands on my clit, and I cry out in surprise and arousal as a tongue laps against it, sending electric currents charging through every nerve in my body.

My feet brace against the mattress, driving my pussy against their mouth. But just as I’m breathing into the relief of the stimulation, they pull away, edging me and denying me what I want the most. It’s maddening, but it’s also one of the most intimate things I’ve ever done—because I’ve completely given up control, putting myself and my pleasure in their hands.

Another cock brushes against my entrance, snapping me out of my thoughts and back into my electrified body. Because of the blindfold and the ropes holding my hands, my other senses feel more awake and alive than ever, and the familiar scent of cognac and amber floods my nose.

“Sebastian,” I whisper automatically, and he chuckles for a second before he slaps the head of his cock lightly against my pussy lips, making me squirm.

“How did you guess already?”

“Your scent. I’d recognize it anywhere.”

“Fuck, baby.”

Sebastian lowers himself down on top of me, pushing his cock into me as he does. My legs wrap around his waist, holding him there and pulling him closer. But he doesn’t move, not yet. Instead, he strokes my cheek and drops a gentle kiss to my parted lips.

“I love that you know us well enough to recognize me by the way I smell,” he says quietly, still stroking my cheek. “It’s amazing, Hailey. Just like the rest of you.”

Unexpected tears burn in the corners of my eyes beneath the blindfold, but I forget all about them when Sebastian draws back, the studs of his piercings sliding across my inner walls.

“Here’s your reward for guessing correctly,” he murmurs. “We’re gonna make you feel so good.”

“You already have,” I breathe, whimpering as he drives back into me.

Someone else’s cock glides across my lips, offering me something to hold in my mouth while Sebastian fucks me, and I take it without a second thought. Their cocks work in unison, driving me right up to the edge when Sebastian pulls out abruptly.

“Not yet, shortcake,” he says and pulls away as the cock I’ve been sucking withdraws.

“Please, I need more,” I beg. “I’m so close. Fuck, please!”

I feel like I’m coming unglued from all this sensory deprivation and stimulation, like my nerves will fray if one of them doesn’t get me over the edge immediately.

But I don’t have to wait long. Someone hikes me up by my waist, sliding their legs under me and resting me on them before driving their cock into me.

“Reid,” I breathe, my back arching.

“Damn right,” he says possessively and works my clit as he pounds away at me. “Gonna make you come until the only thing you remember is our names.”

Someone pinches my clit as Reid fucks me, and I writhe as I come hard.

He follows me over the edge a moment later, and then Nick takes his place again. I don’t even have to guess who it is this time, because I can hear Nick’s deep voice murmuring how beautiful I am and how good I feel as he slides into my wet, cum-soaked pussy.

When Nick comes inside me, grunting out his release, it pushes me over the edge again, and I can feel their combined releases slipping down my inner thighs as Sebastian grips my knees and spreads them wider.

“Look at you,” he groans. “So messy for us. You’re so fucking wet, but goddamn, you’re squeezing me like a vise. I won’t last long, shortcake. Fuck .”

His hips collide with mine over and over as he holds my legs beneath the knees, keeping me right where he wants me. My ass shakes with each thrust, my lower back lifting off the bed. The breathless cries I’ve been trying to hold back bubble up out of me along with my orgasm, and I can feel Sebastian hitting his peak at the same time I do, his cock jerking inside me.

I gasp out his name as pleasure spikes, but as the waves of sensation slowly start to ebb away, they’re replaced by a new wave of emotion.

The tears I felt burning my eyes earlier streak down my cheeks as a rush of feelings rises up like a tidal wave.

Sebastian must notice, because he draws out quickly, releasing his grip on my legs. He shoves the blindfold up my forehead, his expression worried as he stares into my watering eyes.

“What’s wrong?” he murmurs. “Was it too much?”

Without waiting for an answer, he and his brothers hurriedly untie my arms and cradle me between their warm, sweaty bodies.

“Hailey? Are you okay?” Reid asks, pulling my gaze to his by my chin. “Talk to us, baby.”

I laugh through a sob, wiping my eyes quickly with the backs of my hands as I nod.

“I’m fine. Better than fine. I just… I love all three of you so much.”