The Very Naughty List

18. Hailey

18

HAILEY

Sebastian’s words travel right to the spot between my legs. Whatever part of me still can’t believe this is happening falls silent as the rest of me revels in the incredible feeling of having three warm, solid bodies surrounding me. All three of the Cooper brothers are built as fuck, and with so much muscle on display, I feel like a kid at a candy store, wanting all of it and unsure where to even start.

I rise up onto my tiptoes, kissing Sebastian as I rest my hands on his broad chest. But when I draw back and reach for Reid’s belt, desperate to get more of their clothes off, he catches me by the wrist and smirks.

“Uh uh, trouble. What did Sebastian just say?” Reid asks, his voice low.

I blink, staring up at him breathlessly as my brain struggles to function for a second. “That… that I’m going to get fucked the way I deserve.”

“Exactly.” He lifts my wrist, pressing a kiss to the inside of it and making me shiver. “The way you deserve. Which is more than some quick race to the finish line. You’ve had that shit with other guys—and clearly with Dylan too. But not with us. Tonight isn’t gonna be like that. What was it you wrote down?”

Still holding my wrist with one hand, he pulls my list from his back pocket with the other and snaps it open with one easy flick of his wrist. His gaze scans the page quickly, and then he nods, heat smoldering in his blue-gray eyes.

“There it is. ‘I want a guy to get me all worked up and then make me beg for him,’” he reads, lingering on each word. His eyes travel slowly back to mine, and when they meet, his expression darkens. “That sounds like a good place to start.”

Another jolt of heat courses through me as Reid sets the bucket list aside and crushes his lips to mine again, and his brothers chuckle on either side of me. With Reid holding me in place so that he can kiss me senseless, Sebastian attacks the tender skin on my neck while both their hands deftly remove the rest of my clothes. In a matter of seconds, I’m completely naked between them, at their mercy and loving every second of it.

I lose myself in the almost overwhelming feeling of Reid’s and Sebastian’s mouths on me until Nick appears in my peripheral carrying a bottle of whiskey. Reid stops kissing me long enough to notice and pulls me away from his mouth by the hair. With a dark smirk, Nick raises the bottle to my eye level and swishes the contents. A thrill instantly rushes through me because I know what it means and what’s coming.

We’re about to check another item off my list.

“Open,” Nick orders in his rough, commanding voice as Reid holds me in place by the hair. I drop my jaw, never taking my eyes off Nick while he lifts the bottle to his mouth and takes a deep swig from it.

He steps closer, gripping my jaw and tilting my head back. My mouth remains open, my heart thudding with anticipation as he leans over me, his fingers running lightly along the curve of my jaw. Then he parts his lips and spits the whiskey directly into my open mouth. It hits my tongue, spicy and strong, and before I can close my lips to swallow, Nick’s mouth is on mine. Our kiss is tinged with the taste of whiskey as it coats our tongues, and when I finally do swallow it, Nick sweeps his tongue deeper into my mouth as if he’s trying to chase the drink down my throat. It’s so intense that it almost incinerates me, and I let out a plaintive noise against his lips.

“At this rate, we’ll have her list finished in a few hours,” Sebastian jokes to Reid, who chuckles as Nick continues kissing me like a starving man.

“And I bet our dirty girl loves it, doesn’t she?” Reid whispers in my ear, making me whimper again. “Yeah, that’s what I thought.”

“This is only the start, though,” Sebastian adds, his hand sliding over my hip in a leisurely movement. “Like Reid said, this isn’t a quick race to the finish line. If we do this, we’re going to take our time and make sure you have an experience you’ll never forget. Are you sure you can handle it? Can you handle all of us?”

Nick drops his mouth to my neck, giving me a chance to breathe and speak. Despite the tingling in my scalp from Reid’s grip, I turn to face Sebastian.

“Are you sure you can handle me? ”

He chuckles, low and gravelly, and I feel like I’m going to dissolve. “Oh, shortcake. You don’t have a clue what we’re capable of. But you will soon enough.” He glances at his brothers, the three of them sharing a look. “Come on. Let’s show her.”

Nick nods, and Reid lifts me effortlessly into his arms. I yelp in surprise, wrapping my legs around him as he carries me up the stairs. Followed closely by Nick and Sebastian, he takes me to my room and lays me gently down on my bed like I’m the most precious cargo he’s ever handled. It’s a marked difference from the way all three of them were manhandling me downstairs, but it makes me feel safe and lets me trust that, as intense as this night gets, they’re going to take care of me.

As if to prove my point, they surround me on the bed, smiling and stripping off their pants. My eyes can’t settle on just one of them, darting from one set of toned abs to another and back again. Now that it’s happening, I can finally admit that I’ve wanted to see all of these men naked since we were teenagers. But I never pictured it happening like this.

One by one, they crawl onto the bed next to me, their hard, muscled bodies flexing with every movement. I’m sure they’re finally going to fuck me now, but the three of them descend on me instead, their hands and mouths exploring my body.

Nick and Reid settle on either side of me, each of them sucking one of my nipples into their mouths while Sebastian climbs between my legs and shoves them apart by the knees. He lowers himself down, teasing my clit with little flicks of his tongue and warm gusts of his breath.

I moan, tossing my head from side to side, and Reid chuckles, scraping my nipple with his teeth. “Look how sensitive she is. How badly she wants it.”

Nick nods. “Wait until we’re finished with her. She won’t know what hit her.”

“Oh, she’ll know,” Sebastian murmurs against my pussy. “I’ll make sure of that.”

He sucks my clit into his mouth, and I whimper, making all three of them groan.

“You were always meant for better than whatever the fuck Dylan did for you,” Reid says. “Or any other man, for that matter. You were made to be worshipped.”

His words make my breath catch, and when Sebastian starts to fuck me with his tongue, I arch off the bed, feeding more of my breasts to Nick and Reid.

Reid sucks hard on my nipple, then lifts his head with a wet pop. He glances down at where Sebastian’s face is buried between my legs, then grips my chin in one hand to force me to meet his gaze.

“You like that, don’t you, trouble?” he asks. I nod, and he squeezes my jaw. “Say it.”

“I love it.”

“That’s my girl.” His dimples pop out as he smirks and lowers his mouth to mine, cutting off the moan rising at the back of my throat as Sebastian’s tongue pushes apart my folds.

“Fuck, wait until you taste her. She’s so sweet,” Sebastian murmurs, circling my clit again and making me quiver. Honestly, I’m not sure if my reaction is from his words, what he’s doing, or both. The thought of them all eating me out like this is almost too much to bear.

“Let me see,” Nick says, giving my nipple one last lick before elbowing Sebastian out of the way and climbing between my legs. He dives right in, his scruffy beard dragging against my inner thighs. The harsh prickle of it against the sensitive skin gives me chills, but it’s nothing compared to the way it feels when he drags his tongue up my slit.

“Oh my god,” I groan, gripping the sheets as my eyes flutter shut. But they jolt back open when Reid takes my nipple between two fingers and gives it a twist.

“That’s it, eyes on me,” he encourages. “I want to see how good my brother is making you feel.”

I nod, my chest heaving for breath as I hold his gaze, following his command automatically. Even as I stare into Reid’s blue-gray eyes, I still can’t believe this is happening. That I’m being touched like this by not just one of the Cooper triplets, but all three of them—at the same time. If my entire body wasn’t flooded with so much sensation, I’d swear I was dreaming.

But when Sebastian’s mouth finds my clit again, and his tongue starts twirling around it while Nick plunges his tongue into my pussy, I know without a doubt it’s not a dream. I’m being eaten out by two men at the same time, and I’m not going to be able to hold back the orgasm building inside me for much longer.

Reid smiles, clearly reading the ecstasy playing out on my face.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it?” he asks. “To have a man—or more than one—get you all worked up and then make you beg for him?”

I nod eagerly, my bottom lip locked between my teeth to keep from crying out. My legs are starting to shake, my entire body flushed and my clit swollen with arousal. I’ve had guys go down on me before, but never, ever like this. I’ve never come so fast from being eaten out in my life, but I can already feel the tingling sensation growing in my lower belly.

Reid reaches down, tugging my lip free from my teeth before pressing his thumb into my mouth instead. I bite down on it, sucking hard, the same way Sebastian is sucking on my clit. Nick keeps plunging his tongue in and out of me, and I squirm between the three of them, making noises I’ve never made before, my hips shifting as I chase the pleasure of their touch.

“Maybe I’m imagining it,” Reid murmurs, his eyes dark with desire, “but I’d say you’re pretty worked up, aren’t you?”

“Oh my god, yes…”

The word ends on a moan as Sebastian gently locks my clit between his teeth and flicks the tip of his tongue repeatedly against it. It makes my toes curl and little stars pop in my vision, and I’m sure he’s going to keep going until the torrent welling inside me comes crashing out—but he and Nick both pull away at the last second, just before my orgasm breaks.

“Don’t… don’t stop,” I pant when Reid withdraws his thumb from my mouth, writhing on the bed, desperate to get both of their mouths back on me.

“Listen to you, shortcake. You’re so turned on you can barely speak,” Sebastian notes, his arousal coated lips curving into a smile as he lifts his head slightly. He massages my clit with his finger, just barely touching it, and I feel like I’m going to lose my damn mind. My body arches up off the bed, hungry for more of his stimulation, but he pulls out of reach, and I groan in frustration as I sink back against the bed.

Because he’s right. I’m more turned on now than I think I’ve ever been in my life. It’s difficult to think coherently, much less speak. All I want is to come. For one or all of them to take me over the edge I’ve been teetering on.

“You want to get off, don’t you?” Reid asks, but I’m sure he already knows the answer to that question.

“ Yes ,” I breathe.

“Then what are you waiting for? Start begging and maybe we’ll think about letting you.”

His words send a current racing through me, an electric charge that goes right to my pussy. I’m already wet, but a fresh gush of arousal seeps from me as I realize what they’re all waiting for.

“Please,” I whisper. “Please…”

He smirks. “Good start. You look so fucking pretty when you beg. Keep going.”

I swallow hard, my breath coming in sharp gasps. I’ve never talked dirty in the bedroom, since Dylan preferred for me to stay quiet. He never talked dirty either, rolling his eyes every time I asked him to try. I feel a little awkward, unsure of what to say, but the intense need coursing through my veins is like a spark of inspiration.

In this moment, I feel like there’s nothing I wouldn’t say if it would get these men to give me what I need.

“Fuck me,” I breathe, my cheeks heating even as my pussy clenches. “Make me come. I want it so badly. I need it.”

“Even better, shortcake. But we’re gonna need a bit more than that,” Sebastian rasps and takes another teasing swipe at my clit, making me jump. They’re teasing me, denying me what I want, but that only makes it hotter.

“Sebastian’s right.” Reid nods, trailing his finger over the curve of my breast. “That’s not gonna cut it. We already know from your little list that you’re a filthy little slut, deep down. But if you want us to fuck you like one, then you’ll need to tell us exactly what you want.”

I suck in a breath, shocked at the visceral way my body responds to his words. I’ve never been called a slut before, and I don’t know why the hell I find it so hot, but I’m practically panting. It’s like his degrading words have unlocked something in me, something I’ve been hiding for far too long.

But I’m done hiding. And I’m beyond giving a shit that these are my brother’s best friends. All I know right now is that I need to come so badly that I can’t think of anything else.

My eyes snap to Reid’s, and I draw in a deep breath before speaking rapidly.

“I want all three of you to pound me until I’m sore and begging you to stop. I want to feel your hot, sticky cum dripping out of my pussy. And I want you to shut the fuck up and make me come already.”