The Very Naughty List

19. Reid

19

REID

My cock, already hard as hell, pulses as I listen to the filthy words pouring from Hailey’s lips. And when she tacks on that last sentence, her eyes flashing with a challenge, I nearly lose whatever threads of control I had left.

Fucking hell. I should’ve known this girl could ruin me .

She’s so fucking feisty, bratty and sassy in a way that drives me wild.

Naked and spread out on the bed like this, totally vulnerable and willing, she’s fucking gorgeous. It’s wrong to be thinking about my best friend’s sister like this, to be talking to and treating her the way I am. I’ll probably go to hell for this, but I don’t care.

I’ve wanted Hailey for years, but I could never act on it. I knew better. Lucas would kill me if he found out the thought had ever even crossed my mind, and I don’t blame him. If the roles were reversed and he was going after my sister, I’d beat his ass to a pulp too.

But judging from the way Sebastian and Nick are eating Hailey up like she’s the best thing they’ve ever tasted, I know I’m not the only one who’s been craving her. I sensed my brothers were into her before now, even though we never talked about it, and this just confirms it.

And clearly, Hailey’s been hiding some feelings of her own. She’s always had a bit of an edge to her, despite her soft exterior, but I had no idea it ran this deep. I’m almost shocked at the demanding way she just ordered us to make her come.

And I’d be lying if I said it didn’t drive me crazy. So if that’s what this filthy little fiend wants, who am I to say no?

I slide my hand through her hair, palming the back of her head as I kiss her deeply, then pull back to stroke her cheek with my thumb. “Good girl. You did a very good job telling us what you want.”

“And yet here I lie, still waiting,” she sasses me, a smirk tugging at her lips even as her cheeks flush. I’d never tell her this, but I love the brattier side of her because it brings out my most dominant instincts. There’s nothing hotter than a sassy little vixen who’s just begging to be tamed.

“Then get on all fours,” I order, and her eyes flame.

“Oh, now you’re gonna make me do all the work?” she banters back, although she does what she’s told.

Sebastian and Nick lean back to give her room to maneuver, and as soon as she’s on her hands and knees with her beautiful, perky little ass pointing up in the air, I bring a hand back and clap it hard against one of her perfectly round cheeks. She yelps in surprise but moans as she glances over her shoulder at me with a glint in her wide, expressive green eyes.

“Do it again,” she breathes quietly, so I bring my hand down against the other cheek.

“I’m sorry, I couldn’t hear you,” I say over the cry that pours from her lips. My cock pulses at the sight of her wet, glistening pussy and the bright red handprints blooming on both of her ass cheeks.

“I said do it again,” she begs, her voice louder this time.

Fuck. She’s gonna kill me .

I share a look with my brothers, who are both clearly thinking something along the same lines. Then I lift my hand and spank her right ass cheek three times in quick succession. She cries out, her arms wobbling and giving way. Her upper body drops lower as she buries her face in the sheets, arching her back like she’s silently begging for more. She’s so wet now that it’s running down the inside of her leg.

Her ass is so red that it looks like a perfect, fresh strawberry, and I brush my fingertips across the marks I’ve left on her, imagining how good it would feel to sink my teeth into that plump flesh. Goosebumps spread across her skin as she shivers under my touch.

“Fuck,” she mewls into the sheets. “God, fuck , Reid.”

Hearing my name on her lips like that makes me feel almost primal, nearly out of control. All the desire for her that I’ve been holding back for years is rising like a tidal wave inside me, and I don’t think I can hold it back anymore. It’ll tear me apart if I try, and I can’t resist her. Not when she’s kneeling, soaked, and begging for my cock like this.

I can’t wait. I need to be inside her.

I’ve never shared a girl like this with my brothers before, but it feels right with Hailey. If ever there was the perfect woman for us to do it with, it’s her. We all know her better than almost anyone else, and that’s probably why we were all fighting so hard to win her over even though the whole thing was supposed to be fake.

None of us could ever just sit back and let the others have her. I can’t speak for Nick and Sebastian, but seeing her with either of them would’ve eaten me alive with jealousy. But working together to get her off? Shit, that’s easy.

“Quit torturing me and fuck me already,” Hailey mumbles into the sheets, rocking her hips back as if searching for a cock to fill her up.

I have to show her who’s really in charge here, so I thrust a finger all the way inside her, filling her up until she cries out, her head lifting off the mattress as her back arches.

Nick takes the opportunity to reach under her for her nipple, working it between two fingers while I roughly add a second finger and drive them both in and out of her. If she wants me to fuck her like a hungry little whore, then that’s exactly what I’ll do.

“Condoms?” I grunt, moving into place behind her as Sebastian tucks a lock of Hailey’s wavy honey blonde hair behind her ear.

“I’m on the pill.” Hailey shakes her head as she rocks forward and backward on my fingers, squeezing and pulling them deeper into her like she can’t get enough. “Are you all clean?”

“Yeah. We get tested regularly. Everything’s clear,” Nick says as he keeps working her nipple. Hailey whimpers and looks over her shoulder at me.

“Then we don’t need protection. I don’t want to use condoms. I want to feel everything. Please…”

I can’t fight the groan that wells in my chest, and it rumbles past my lips as I withdraw my fingers and start pressing my swollen cock into her. “I don’t want anything between us either. You feel so damn good, trouble. It would kill me not to be able to feel every exquisite inch of you choking my cock.”

“Yesss…”

Hailey exhales, long and slow, as I work my way inside. My shaft disappears into her tight pussy inch by inch, and when I finally bottom out inside her, she shudders, her entire body trembling.

“Fuck! Oh my god, Reid. Please, fuck me. I need… I need…”

“I know,” I rasp, drawing out and driving back in. “Touch yourself for me, baby. You’ve done such a good job holding on. Now it’s time for you to come like we promised. Get yourself off while you take my cock.”

I fuck her in a hard, steady pace, and she turns her head to one side, resting her cheek against the sheets as she reaches between her legs for her clit.

Her fingers are a blur on the little nub as she chases her climax, and I grit my teeth, trying to keep a tight rein on my own pleasure.

When she finally falls apart on my cock, clenching and spasming around it, it feels fucking incredible. Hailey gasps for air and whimpers as she falls to pieces, and combined with the way she’s gripping my shaft like a vise, it’s almost too much for me to take. But somehow, I manage to keep it together until she finishes, burying myself inside her and going still as the tremors work through her body.

I take a second to gather myself and to give her a chance to catch her breath in the aftermath of her orgasm, then slowly start dragging my cock out of her. She inhales sharply, her body jolting with the sensation, but when she exhales, she relaxes just a bit, and I drive all the way back into her.

“Holy shit,” she hisses. “It feels so… so intense.”

“Can you take more?”

“Yes,” she answers immediately, her blonde hair spreading out around her head as she gives a messy nod. She presses back up onto her hands, holding herself on all fours despite the way her arms still shake.

“Good, because you’re about to get a lot fucking more.”

“From all of us,” Nick adds.

He reaches down to grip his cock, giving it a long stroke, and Hailey lets out the sexiest, dirtiest little growl of approval. I had no idea she could be this responsive, this eager, but I fucking love it, and I can’t wait to see what other sides of herself she’s been keeping from us.

“Give it to me. I want it all,” she whispers, reaching for Nick.

He lets her stroke him while I keep driving into her from behind, and something about the sight of her so desperate for all of us makes heat surge in my veins. Sharing a woman with my brothers like this wasn’t exactly on my bucket list, but now that we’re here, now that I’m watching her stroke his cock while taking mine? It’s fucking perfect.

Sebastian settles his back against the headboard, jerking himself off deliberately as he watches the scene play out in front of him, and when Hailey’s gaze shifts to him, I can only imagine the hungry look in her eyes. He smirks, squeezing the head of his dick before spreading precum over his pierced shaft.

“Don’t worry, shortcake,” he promises, his gaze locked with hers. “There’s plenty more to go around.”

“And it’s all for you,” Nick says, shifting his position beside us a bit so that he can reach between her legs for her clit. He toys with her, and I watch her ribs expand with each breath as I slide in and out of her. She’s so wet from her first orgasm that there’s barely any friction, but she’s so tight that it makes white light cloud my vision every time I bottom out. “We’re gonna make you come over and over.”

“Don’t let your mouth write checks your cocks can’t cash,” Hailey shoots back, and Nick chuckles darkly at her before he pinches her clit between his fingers.

She whimpers and spasms around my cock. Her back arches and she stops breathing, so I pick up the pace, my hips slapping against her ass as I fuck her roughly, until finally she releases the breath she’s been holding and dissolves into an orgasm all over again.

It’s about to push me over the edge too, but before she finishes her climax and takes me with her, I stop moving. I want to come, but not like this. She stays on her hands and knees, heaving for breath with her ass pointed in the air as her body slowly comes down from the high.

“We’re gonna cross off another item from your list,” I tell her in a low voice, and she glances over her shoulder at me.

“What do you mean?” she whispers.

“You’re gonna suck me off while Nick fucks you.”

Hailey’s warm, wet pussy tightens around me, making it clear just how into the idea she is, so I smirk at her and spank her ass once more before I pull out. Nick moves around behind her as we trade places. As he settles between her legs, I kneel next to Hailey on the bed and take a fistful of her hair to direct her mouth to my dick while Nick grips her hips, making her eyelids flutter.

“Open wide, trouble,” I command.

I drag the tip of my cock against her lips to prompt her, my blood heating at the little whimper that leaks out of her mouth.

“If it’s too much, tap my thigh,” I say, dropping my head to catch her gaze. “I’m not gonna take it easy on you, but you’re still in control. Got it?”

She nods, her eyes wide and luminous. When her mouth drops open, I slide my cock between her full lips, and she groans around me. I have no idea how many times she’s done this, but the way she starts bobbing on my length immediately makes her look filthy and eager in the best way.

“Fuck, that’s it. Suck my fucking cock,” I grunt, keeping her hair locked in my fist so I can guide her movements. “You wanted to see how bossy I can be? Here you go.”

I thrust my cock deeper, hitting the back of her throat, and she whimpers as Nick presses into her at the same time.

“Goddamn, you got this pussy nice and warmed up for me, Reid,” Nick grunts, his gaze locked on the place where he’s sliding in and out of Hailey.

“Maybe I’ll get her mouth good and ready for you next.” I drag Hailey off my cock for a moment to look her in the eyes. “Would you like that?”

In answer, she lunges for me again, taking my length all the way down her throat until her nose brushes my lower abs. Nick is rougher with the way he fucks her, more intense, just like he is about pretty much everything, but Hailey doesn’t seem to mind. In fact, it only seems to unleash her inner vixen even more. She seems completely lost to the pleasure of it as she rocks between us.

“God, I can’t wait to feel you work my cock like that,” Sebastian tells Hailey as he keeps stroking himself. “But I’m in no hurry. We all know you’re saving the best for last.”

That gets a chuckle out of me. “I dunno about that. Looks like she’s having the time of her life to me.”

“She’s taking us so damn well,” Nick tells him, and Hailey groans again around my shaft. The vibration travels right to my balls, and I know I’m getting close. Hell, I was right on the edge before Nick and I traded, but her mouth feels just as good as her pussy did.

“See? Just like I told you, we’re going to fuck you like you deserve,” I tell her hoarsely, and she sucks me faster in response, gagging on my cock.

“ Fuck ,” I grunt, my head tipping back. “You’re gonna make me come if you keep that up, trouble. Is that what you want?”

“Yes. Yes . Give it to me. Let me taste you,” she begs, her words coming out in short gasps as she draws back for a second. Her hand wraps around my shaft and squeezes, and she follows her mouth up and down my length.

“You’ve got to earn it first. I want to see you come again. Give Nick the same ride you gave me,” I tell her. “Let him feel how tight you get when you fall apart.”

I pull her off my cock again, since I know I won’t be able to last with her mouth on me. She stares up into my eyes, her deep green irises flashing in the light, before she narrows them and bites her lower lip.

With a determined expression, she starts throwing her hips backward to meet Nick’s hard thrusts. Her face contorts with each pump, and little groans and whimpers spill out of her until their rhythm gets so fast that she can’t control herself anymore.

“There you go, give in to it. When you do, I’ll give you something to keep you quiet,” I tell her, gripping my cock at the base. She tries to take it in her mouth, but I don’t let her, and her whimper sounds like a mixture of frustration and arousal. She really does want it badly, and that drives me fucking crazy.

Truth is, I could come at any second just from watching Nick take her from behind like this. And that intense look she’s giving me isn’t helping. I squeeze my cock again while I watch to keep myself right on the edge, my heart thumping hard against my ribs, until finally her jaw drops and her brows stitch together.

“Oh my god,” she whimpers as Nick’s thrusts turn erratic.

I know she’s about to come, so I grip her chin and slide my cock back down her throat. She sputters around it, sliding her tongue along my shaft and swallowing over and over as I hit my peak right along with her. She sucks me hungrily, hollowing her cheeks, and I feel like she’s drawing a piece of my soul out through my cock.

It’s intense and easily the hardest I’ve come in my whole life, but somehow, she swallows it all and keeps sucking me through the aftershocks as my hips jerk and buck.

“So fucking good,” Nick groans, baring his teeth as he stills inside her. “Jesus, I’m not ready to come yet.”

She shudders between us, filled completely by the two of us until my cock finally starts to soften and slips from her mouth. I release Hailey’s hair and massage her scalp, worried I might have been too rough with her, but she grips my semi-hard cock in one hand and laps at it softly, cleaning me up while Nick gives her a break.

I tip her chin up to meet my gaze, then lean over to kiss her. I taste my cum on her tongue, and it makes my spent cock twitch like it’s trying to rise again already.

“Fuck, that’s so hot,” I whisper when we part, and she grins at me like the little sex demon she is. “Do you think you can still take more?”

A flash of trepidation passes through her expression, reminding me that despite how well she’s been doing, this is all new for her.

But there’s not a hint of doubt in her voice as she nods and whispers, “I don’t want this to ever end.”