The Very Naughty List

20. Hailey

20

HAILEY

Nick lets out a low noise behind me, his grip on my hips tightening as his cock pulses. I’m so sensitive from how many times I’ve come already that he feels even bigger than he is—and he’s fucking huge.

Both he and Reid have been giving me so much pleasure that it’s impossible to focus on just one particular part of it. It’s overwhelming in the best way, so I’m thankful for the breather, even though I meant it when I told Reid that I didn’t want this to end.

I can’t get enough. I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to.

Reid grins down at me, his blue-gray eyes flashing with something that almost looks like pride, and wipes the corner of my mouth with his thumb.

“Good,” he says, then turns to Sebastian. “Get over here and see how fucking good this mouth feels.”

My heart pounds in my chest as Sebastian takes Reid’s place, his swollen, pierced cock jutting out from his body. I lick my lips, staring at it. Ever since I learned about his piercings, I’ve been dying to know what they’d feel like inside me, and knowing that I’m about to find out makes me whine softly with desire.

I fist his cock gently, then tilt it up a bit more to admire the studs lining the underside of it. There are at least ten of them, and I can’t stop myself from dragging my tongue up the line of piercings, lingering on each stud.

“Don’t be scared. Suck it.”

Sebastian’s voice is rough, and I realize in a rush that it’s because of me. His cock pulses against my palm, a dribble of precum leaking from the tip as if it’s begging me to take it into my mouth.

“I’m not scared,” I whisper, and it’s the truth. “I think it’s hot.”

“Good.” He swallows. “Because like I told you, I got them for you.”

I can’t help the way my body reacts to those words, and Nick grunts as I clench around him. Sebastian moves a little closer, allowing me to take him into my mouth, and I slowly work my way down his shaft, feeling the studs slide against my tongue on my way down.

“Mm,” Sebastian groans. “That feels so fucking good, shortcake. Just wait until you feel them inside your pussy. You’re gonna love it.”

I draw back a bit, but Nick starts fucking me again before I can say anything in response, turning the start of my words into a moan. The image of riding Sebastian’s cock, feeling his piercings rub against me in all the right ways, sends a shiver of arousal through me.

Nick must pick up on it, because he starts pounding away at me again, his powerful hands and fingers digging into my waist as he uses that grip to hold me steady. My entire body responds to his thrusting, deepening the arch in my back so I can take him even deeper.

“You were made for this,” Sebastian murmurs, trailing his fingers lightly over my cheek. “Your mouth feels like heaven, wrapped around me.”

“You have no fucking idea, Seb,” Nick mutters, his voice a strained rasp. “Fuck, you’re blowing my mind, songbird.”

The praise makes my body sing, and it goes right to my head. This entire night has felt like something out of a dream—a filthy perfect dream—and I love how effortlessly they can go from talking to me like their dirty little whore to their prized princess. I want to be both of those things for them. I’d gladly do anything they ask, as long as they don’t stop.

“I’m gonna fill you up. Gonna come inside this tight pussy. Can you handle that?” Nick asks, slowing down his movements. I don’t answer, instead throwing my hips back onto his cock, and he lets out a sound somewhere between a laugh and a groan. “I’ll take that as a yes.”

With another grunt and a hard thrust into me, he erupts, and a moan gets trapped in my throat as I feel his warmth flooding me. I rock my hips back and forth, milking every last drop out of him while I keep sucking furiously on Sebastian’s cock.

“Me too.” Sebastian’s jaw is tight, his eyes hooded. “Fuck, watching them fuck you got me so close to the edge. I can’t last much longer. Come with us, baby. Come on. One more time.”

I’m about to shake my head, since there’s no way I should be able to finish again… but before I can, a tingling sensation starts to flood my veins, and I realize I was wrong.

Fuck. Fuck, fuck…

My final orgasm hits me like a comet, harder and faster than any of the times I’ve come before. I writhe between them, whimpering and drooling on Sebastian’s cock as my body trembles like it has a fever it’s trying to sweat out.

“Fuck, Hailey. Don’t stop, don’t stop, right there?—”

Sebastian breaks off with a curse as he comes too, and I’m vaguely aware of swallowing his release as the pleasure wracking my body seems to go on and on. I lose track of time and space while the climax rocks me, and when I float back into my body and consciousness a few seconds later, I find Sebastian beaming down at me.

“Ho-ly shit,” he drawls, gently brushing my sweat-soaked hair out of my face. “That was incredible to watch, shortcake. You’re something else.”

“You’re fucking right about that,” Nick agrees, pulling out slowly and slapping my ass with one hand.

I jump, but I can barely take in their words because I’m borderline delirious from all the orgasms I’ve had. I’ve never come this many times in a row before—but I can tell from the way Sebastian is looking at me that this won’t be the last time either.

“You need a break, baby?” he asks, squeezing his slowly deflating cock before stroking it a few times. “It’s been a lot. None of us would judge you for tapping out.”

My eyes widen, a surge of the competitive drive that he always brings out in me flooding my chest.

There’s never been a challenge Sebastian Cooper laid down that I didn’t rise to, and this certainly isn’t going to be the first.

“Are you worried you’ll lose our bet?” I shoot back, although the sass I was going for is a bit ruined by the rasp in my voice from deep-throating two cocks.

He arches a brow, his cock thickening as he strokes it again. “Are you reconsidering my dare?”

“Fuck, no.” I lunge forward a little, wrapping my lips around the head of his cock to prove it, and his chuckle morphs into a deep, guttural groan as his cock swells.

When I pop off him for air, he laughs again. “Okay, okay. I get it. You’re not backing down from the dare.”

“Definitely not.”

“Good.” He catches my chin and leans down to kiss me, then whispers against my lips. “Because you’re gonna ride my pierced cock just like your bucket list says.”

I fight back a shiver, turned on all over again just by the thought. “Are you really ready to go again? I thought guys usually needed longer than that to recover.”

He chuckles, glancing down at his cock, which is fully hard again. “I guess my body makes an exception to that rule when there’s a goddess in my bed.”

I know he’s probably just being his usual flirtatious self, but that doesn’t stop my heart from thudding against my ribs as he straightens up and turns to his brothers.

“I want her to ride me. Help her up.”

Nick and Reid grab me under each arm, lifting me carefully. Sebastian lies down underneath me, and his brothers lower me down onto his cock like a queen on her throne.

He’s a lot to take, unlike anything I’ve ever felt before, and I’m not sure if I can do it. It’s hot as hell, but it feels a little weird and uncomfortable. Sebastian rubs my thighs.

“It’s okay, just breathe. You can do this, baby.” I wince as Reid and Nick let me go and Sebastian slides deeper into me. He reaches up and cups my cheek with one hand. “You trust me, right? You know I’d never hurt you.”

“None of us would. And if any of us tried, the other two would kill him,” Reid says, his eyes flashing possessively as he watches his brother’s pierced cock disappear inside me.

“I trust all three of you,” I say firmly, pressing down another inch. I’ve been fantasizing about this ever since we crossed naked paths in the hallway, and now that the moment’s finally here, I’m not about to let anything ruin it.

“Then breathe, shortcake,” Sebastian says, still holding my face in one of his hands. I nod and take a deep breath, then let it out slowly. “There you go. Just like that. I’m halfway in. Before you know it, you’ll have all of me inside you.”

That makes me want him even more than I already do, so I repeat the breathing several times until Sebastian lets out a shuddering groan.

“Look down, shortcake,” he murmurs. “Look how fucking well you take me.”

I glance down to the place where I’m stretched around him, and my breath catches as I realize I’ve done it. Every inch of his pierced cock is inside me. It’s a filthy sight, my pussy flushed and swollen, my wetness and Nick’s cum smeared across my thighs—but somehow, it’s perfect too. It’s a visceral reminder that all of this isn’t just a dream. It’s messy, and it’s real .

“Fuck me,” I whisper, the words coming easier than they did the first time I begged these men. “Fuck me, Sebastian. Show me what it’s like.”

A determined look passes across his face, and he bucks his hips upward, splitting me open with his cock. I gasp in surprise, falling forward a bit and bracing my hands on his chest. It feels incredible, and I swear I can feel each of the studs of his piercings inside me.

“Oh my god,” I hiss. Those are the only words I can manage to speak. I’ve never felt anything like this before, and I love it. It’s better than anything my fantasies could’ve ever cooked up, and Sebastian must know it, because the smile that spreads across his face is ravenous.

“Everything okay?”

“It’s fucking perfect,” I breathe.

“Just like you.” He bucks up into me again. “Work your clit for me, baby. I want to see you get yourself off while you ride my dick.”

I do it immediately, somehow forgetting that I wasn’t sure I could come even once more several minutes ago. Now I feel desperate for another orgasm, for a release to all the pleasure building inside me.

“Holy fuck,” I gasp as Sebastian settles into a rhythm beneath me. One of my hands slides down to circle my clit, and my free hand flails until Reid catches it and links his fingers between mine, squeezing tight. Nick strokes one of my shoulders and rests his other hand on top of mine above my clit like he wants me to show him how to please me. Like he wants to help.

“We’ve got you, songbird,” he murmurs into my ear, his lips whispering against my lobe and turning my skin into a battlefield of sensations fighting for my focus. Determination flares somewhere inside me, and I use Reid’s hand to steady myself as I start bouncing on Sebastian’s cock, my fingers and Nick’s working my clit together.

“Never knew it would be like this,” Sebastian says intensely, staring into my eyes. “Better than I ever could’ve imagined.”

His words, combined with the pierced cock driving in and out of me steadily, are almost too much for me to handle. My body and brain feel like they’re on overload, and every time his studs slide against my walls, massaging my pussy lips, my breath catches.

My head falls back as a moan starts working its way up my throat. Sebastian’s thrusts take on a new tone, faster and more desperate, like he’s racing me to the finish line.

“Fuck! Fuck , don’t stop,” I mewl as I grind my fingers in harsh circles against my clit and crash into the most intense orgasm I’ve had so far.

Reid helps me stay upright, and Nick keeps massaging my clit as every nerve ending in my body catches fire. Sebastian fucks me through it, taking deep, hard strokes. Our bodies clap together, and I feel myself soaking him, squeezing and flexing around his cock, until finally he bucks into me one last time and lets out a shuddering groan.

I keep bouncing on him, working him over with my pussy, while he floods me with his cum, and he never takes his blazing blue-green eyes off mine. It’s like he can see into my soul, like he can see the exact moment when I fall apart for him.

It goes on for what feels like forever, and when my muscles finally start to relax, I wilt against Reid, who catches me against his chest and helps lower me off Sebastian onto the bed. I snuggle up against Sebastian’s toned, sweat-slicked chest, and Reid lies down behind me, sandwiching me between the two of them.

Nick looks down at the three of us for a moment, his thick dark brows drawn together as he takes in the sight of us. Unabashedly naked, he strides from the room, his tree trunk thighs and muscled ass flexing with each step. I hear the faucet running down the hall before he returns with a wet, warm wash cloth. Reid rolls me onto my back, and he and Sebastian work together to spread my cum-soaked legs apart so Nick can kneel between them and gently wipe my thighs and pussy.

I’m sex-dazed and already feeling sore in muscles I didn’t know I had, but it’s still one of the most tender, surprising things I’ve ever had a guy do for me. It never would’ve crossed Dylan’s mind, that’s for sure.

“Thank you,” I murmur, struggling to keep my eyes open, and Nick raises an eyebrow at me. “You don’t have to do that. It feels nice, though.”

He frowns. “What? You’ve never had a guy take care of you like this after sex?”

“No,” I admit sheepishly.

Reid grunts, anger clear in his tone. “Are you fucking serious? That piece of shit ex-fiancé of yours never did this?”

My face flushes, because they’re making me feel like I’ve been accepting scraps for my entire life. Maybe I have .

I shake my head, shrugging one shoulder. “No. Like you said, he was a piece of shit.”

“He’s worse than that. He’s a fucking parasite.”

Sebastian nods in agreement, bringing my hand to his mouth to kiss it gently. “You deserve so much better than him and what he did to you, shortcake.”

A sudden wave of emotion tightens my throat and steals my breath. How are these men all so good to me? I’m not sure if I believe them that I deserve it, and I have no idea what will happen next, but I’m so grateful that they gave me this night.

That they showed me how good things can be.

“Thanks,” I whisper, blinking quickly to banish the tears that burn in my eyes. I’m not sure I trust my voice enough to say anything else, so I snuggle back up against Sebastian’s chest, his heart beating softly in my ear.

Reid settles on our other side again, with Nick on that side too. The brothers keep talking to each other, and I catch bits of their conversation, but it’s hard to keep my eyes open with three warm bodies surrounding mine and Sebastian’s steady heartbeat lulling me to sleep.

My eyelids flutter until I can’t fight their heaviness, and they fall closed.