True Love (The Society #4)

Chapter 26 – Chocolate Chip Cookies

Monday – March 11, 2024

Tanner

Her pussy felt better than I could ever have imagined. I slammed deep inside of her, making her moan again.

I wanted to experience every angle. Every position. I wanted all of it.

I pulled her back up, grabbed her hips, and carried her over to one of the walls by the monitors. I slammed her back against it, knocking off a few framed pictures. Glass shattered onto the ground.

Ash tried to wrap her hands behind my neck, but I grabbed her hands and pinned the back of them against the wall.

She gripped my cock.

Fuck I liked this position. I used to love this position too as I devoured her pussy. Where she was completely at my mercy. But she was even more at my mercy now. I fucked her hard against the wall. It was so hard not to cum again. I had no idea how good this would feel.

But I needed to last longer this time. I wanted her to forget about all the other men she’d ever been with. Nigel and I had erased quite a few guys’ memories. But I’d thought Ash had been lying about a lot of it. And I definitely hadn’t wiped everyone’s.

All that mattered was that she forgot about those other guys though .

Her next moan sounded different. I looked over at the monitors where she was sliding between two gladiators’ cocks.

“You liked being a little slut for me, didn’t you?” I whispered in her ear.

“Yes.”

“You liked gagging on that gladiator’s cock? Were you imagining deepthroating mine?” I bit down on her earlobe.

“Yes,” she moaned again.

“And you pictured my cock sliding into you from behind? My fingers on your hips?”

“Tanner.” Her breath hitched.

“You don’t need to imagine it anymore.” I slowly pulled out of her and set her down. I needed a second to calm down, but seeing her standing there naked just pulled me even closer to the edge. “Turn around,” I said.

She spun around.

“Hands on the wall, baby.”

She followed my instructions, arching her back.

I groaned as I pushed her dress back up over her hips, exposing her bare ass. No one else was ever going to touch my girl again. I looked over at the monitor as another gladiator slid into her from behind. My fingers dug into Ash’s hips as I slammed into her.

She almost faceplanted the wall from the thrust. But soon she was pushing back on the wall, matching the rhythm.

I reached around her waist and ran my thumb across her clit. There was one more thing I had been dreaming of. The feeling of her pulsing around my cock instead of my fingers. I traced slow circles around her clit, just the way she liked.

My hips moved faster. Fucking her better than the gladiator in the video had. Giving her exactly what she needed to... Fuck. I felt her pussy clenching around me.

That. That feeling right there. It was my new favorite feeling in the world.

She kept pushing back on the wall.

That’s right, baby. Ride my cock.

“I think it’s time I put that baby in you,” I said. I couldn’t hold it together anymore. I was seconds away from losing control.

She looked over her shoulder at me. “I so badly want that.”

I was just about to cum when she said: “But...”

I groaned, trying to control myself.

“I went back on birth control. And I’ve been desperate to know what kind of cookies your cum will taste like.”

“On your knees,” I said through clenched teeth and pulled out of her.

She spun around, got down on her knees, and opened wide.

Good girl. I started stroking myself and immediately exploded. I aimed it right at her mouth.

This was so much better than skeeting into some water. I kept stroking myself. It felt like a dream drenching her. I watched her greedily drink it down. And then she started licking her lips.

Fuck that’s hot.

She smiled up at me.

“What’s the verdict?” I asked .

“Chocolate chip cookies.” She looked so excited. “They’re my favorite. Not too sweet. And you can eat like a billion at once.” She eyed my cock greedily.

God I loved this girl.

The door started to unlock.

Shit. I grabbed Ash’s hand and helped her to her feet.

Rob walked in just as I zipped up my pants. “What the fuck?!” he yelled.